Varanava & Ors v Turkey20, the European Court of Human Rights held:
"184. As a logical development of this approach, in the situaon
where persons are found injured or dead, or who have
disappeared, in an area within the exclusive control of the
authories of the State and there is prima facie evidence that the
State may be involved, the burden of proof may also shi to the
Government since the events in issue may lie wholly, or in large
part, within the exclusive knowledge of the authories. If they
then fail to disclose crucial documents to enable the Court to
establish the facts or otherwise provide a satisfactory and
convincing explanaon, strong inferences may be drawn.”
71.4.
Bleier v Uruguay 21, the Human Rights Commiee of the United Naons
held:
"13.3 With regard to the burden of proof, this cannot rest alone
on the author of the communicaon, especially considering that
the author and the State party do not always have equal access to
the evidence and that frequently the State party alone has access
to relevant informaon ... In cases where the author has
submied to the Commiee allegaons supported by substanal
witness tesmony, as in this case, and where further clarificaon
of the case depends on information exclusively in the hands of the
State party, the Commiee may consider such allegaons as
substanated in the absence of sasfactory evidence and
explanaons to the contrary submied by the State party.”
72.
Thus, the burden of proof in cases of enforced disappearances rests with the
State. This means that the Panel is entled to accept inferences submied by
Counsel on behalf of the family, Assisng Officers of SUHAKAM and Counsel of
the Bar Council against the State. It is for the State to adduce sasfactory
evidence and give explanaons on a balance of probabilies to show that the
State was not in any way involved in the disappearance of the person within the
definion of enforced disappearance under Arcle 2 of ICPPED.
20
Appl. nos. 16064/90, 16065/90, 16066/90, 16068/90, 16069/90, 16070/90, 16071/90, 16072/90 and 16073/90, Council
of Europe: European Court of Human Rights, 18 September 2009
21 Communicaon No. R.7/30, 29 March 1982.
27
PASTOR RAYMOND KOH
71.3.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents