Promoting and Protecting the Rights of Migrant Workers The Role of National Human Rights Institutions For example, individuals and families who have fled persecution and are seeking asylum in another country, along with those who have been trafficked across national borders, should not be criminalized for entering a country in an irregular fashion. As the Special Rapporteur on the human rights of migrants has noted: … it is important that irregular migration be seen as an administrative offence and irregular migrants processed on an individual basis. Where possible, detention should be used only as a last resort and in general irregular migrants should not be treated as criminals. The often erratic and unlawful detention of migrants is contributing to the broader phenomenon of the criminalization of irregular migration.273 Migrants who do come into contact with law enforcement agencies, detaining authorities and the judicial system commonly face significant challenges and barriers. These can include little or no understanding of their legal rights or the legal process of the country, language barriers, limited resources and difficulties in securing legal services and other support. Furthermore, migrants may not be informed of their right to communicate with consular officials when arrested or detained and they may have little or no right to challenge the lawfulness of their detention. NHRIs can advocate for changes to national laws and policies that promote access to justice and due process for all migrants, based on international human rights standards and the principle of nondiscrimination: States should take measures to review their national laws applicable to the detention of migrants to ensure that they are harmonized with international human rights norms that prohibit inhumane treatment and ensure due process. States should take measures to ensure that detention of irregular migrants is not arbitrary and that there is a national legal framework to govern detention procedures and conditions.274 The “[g]rounds for detention must be clearly and exhaustively defined and the legality of detention must be open for challenge before a court and regular review within fixed time limits”.275 In addition, it is vital that migrants have access to information in a language they understand “regarding the nature of their detention, the reasons for it, the process for reviewing or challenging the decision to detain. It should also be presented in a form that takes account of the individual’s level of education.”276 In cooperation with others – such as consular services, NGOs and civil society groups – NHRIs can also develop strategies and recommendations to facilitate access to legal aid and other services that promote the equality of migrants before the law.277 The detention of migrants should not be arbitrary, unnecessary or disproportionate. It should be used as a last resort and for the shortest period of time and “alternatives to detention shall be sought whenever possible, all of which particularly concern the deprivation of liberty applied to asylum-seekers, refugees and irregular migrants”.278 Numerous studies have highlighted the serious, negative impact of prolonged administrative detention on migrants. Being detained for an unspecified time can have profound, long-term effects on the mental 273 Report of the Special Rapporteur on the human rights of migrants; UN Human Rights Council; A/HRC/7/12; p. 17. 274 Ibid; p. 21. 275 Report of the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention; UN Human Rights Council; A/HRC/10/21; p. 23. 276 Migration and International Human Rights Law; Practitioner’s Guide No. 6; International Commission of Jurists; 2011; p. 151. 277 The Special Rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers has noted: “It is commonplace for such persons to be deprived of access to the courts, owing to their administrative situation. This vulnerability is particularly distressing for asylumseekers, for whom access to justice is crucial if they are to avoid irreversible prejudice such as a violation of the principle of non-refoulement. It is reasonable and mandatory to provide not only free legal aid, but also interpretation, and at times forensic psychological or medical, services. However, according to recent research, access to justice free of charge is made subject to conditions that make it unattainable in practice.” UN Human Rights Council; A/HRC/8/4; p. 24. 278 Report of the Working Group on Arbitrary Detention; UN Human Rights Council; A/HRC/10/21; p. 25. 110 | Chapter 8: Protecting the rights of migrants in detention

Select target paragraph3

Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents