Promoting and Protecting the Rights of Migrant Workers The Role of National Human Rights Institutions
CASE STUDY
Although New Zealand is not a party to the International Convention on
the Protection of All Migrant Workers and Members of their Families,
the Human Rights Commission of New Zealand does monitor the
circumstances of specific categories of migrant workers included in the
Convention, including ‘seafarers’.
In 2010, the Commission became aware of significant claims of labour
and human rights abuses involving Indonesia seafarers who were working
aboard a Korean-owned vessel before this vessel sunk off the coast of New
Zealand. It contacted the National Human Rights Commission of Indonesia
(Komnas Ham) for assistance and advice on the capacity of Komnas Ham
to protect those nationals from punishment or retribution by “recruitment/
manning agencies” on their return. It also raised the matter with the
National Human Rights Commission of Korea (NHRCK).
In November 2011, the Commission also presented a submission to
the Ministerial Inquiry into Foreign Charter Vessels in which it strongly
supported fair and decent conditions for the crews of foreign charter
vessels. The Commission used its submission to promote the use of the
Ruggie Principles244 on business and human rights, adopted by the UN
General Assembly. The Commission’s recommendations were informed by
discussions with Komnas Ham, the NHRCK and the Chair of the ASEAN
Intergovernmental Human Rights Commission.
8. MONITORING AND INVESTIGATING SYSTEMIC VIOLATIONS
AGAINST MIGRANT WORKERS
244
NHRIs should, where relevant, monitor, investigate and initiate complaints to protect the rights
of migrant workers. As part of ongoing monitoring efforts, include a migration related section,
including regarding the impact on development, in their annual reports. Special reports are
encouraged where appropriate.
Santa Cruz Declaration245
NHRIs have a responsibility to regularly monitor the human rights circumstances of all migrant workers,
including undocumented workers and migrants in an irregular situation.
To ensure that there is a consistent focus on these issues, an NHRI might assign responsibility for this
monitoring work to a specific member or department within the NHRI.246 It might also assign one or
more staff members as “focal point” officers on the rights of migrant workers, with clear duties in relation
to monitoring and outreach activities.247
244
The Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights rest on three pillars: the duty of the State to protect against human rights
abuses; corporate responsibility to respect human rights; and greater access for victims to effective remedy.
245
Santa Cruz Declaration; 8th International Conference of National Institutions for the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights;
Santa Cruz, Republic of Bolivia; 24–26 October 2006; para. 29.
246
For example, the New Zealand Human Rights Commission has a dedicated Equal Employment Opportunity Commissioner. One
of the Commission’s key activities in this area is the “operation of a timely, accessible and impartial dispute resolution service to
answer questions and resolve complaints of unlawful discrimination and harassment in the workplace”.
247
For example, the National Human Rights Committee of Qatar undertakes a number of inspection visits each month to places
of employment of migrant workers and workers’ residences “to observe their situations or to play an intermediary role between
them and [their] employer”; see the NHRC’s report to the 15th Annual Meeting of the Asia Pacific Forum of National Human Rights
Institutions; Bali, Indonesia; 3–5 August 2010; p. 4.
98 | Chapter 7: Investigating allegations of human rights violations
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents