Introduction
Te Kāhui Tika Tangata Human Rights Commission has received requests from religious
communities for support and information on the Conversion Practices Prohibition Legislation Act
2022, which makes conversion practices unlawful in Aotearoa New Zealand.
Some want to understand the new legal requirements.
Others want to make their communities affirming
spaces where conversion practices would be
unthinkable.
Research published in Aotearoa in 2023 found young
people experiencing conversion practices:
In this document we use the term religious community
to refer to a group of people who share the same
religious faith – whether this is an organised religion or
an informal faith group.
Accepting and affirming
Using terms preferred by the LGBTQIA+ community
shows respect, fosters inclusivity, breaks down
stereotypes, and builds trust which will lead to a more
supportive environment for everyone. We use the term
‘accepting’ to mean religious communities where
LGBTQIA+ people are welcome as themselves with no
pressure to hide or change their identity.
Beyond accepting, some religious communities identify
as ‘affirming and inclusive’, which means actively
integrating LGBTQIA+ people into all parts of their
community, including leadership. There are a range
of practices and behaviours (policy and non-policy)
that can support LGBTQIA+ people to be and feel safe
in religious spaces. More terms are included in the
Glossary section of the document.
What are conversion practices?
Conversion practices are actions taken towards
an individual with the intention of changing or
suppressing their sexual orientation, gender identity,
or gender expression. They are sometimes referred to
as ‘conversion therapy’.
These practices are typically directed at members
of the LGBTQIA+, takatāpui Māori and MVPFAFF+
Pasifika communities. They reflect a belief system,
known as conversion ideology, which asserts that
being part of these communities is wrong and can be
changed.i
Harmed caused by conversion practices
Even though conversion practices occasionally appear
to provide short term results they inevitably fail and
cause significant harm. Evidence, internationally and
in Aotearoa, shows survivors of conversion practices
experience mental distress, withdrawal and isolation,
negative career impacts, physical health symptoms,
and suicidal thoughts, plans and attempts.ii
22
•
had increased frequency of non-suicidal self-injury
•
had double the risk of planning suicide
•
had triple the risk of attempting suicide.iii
The level of harm increases significantly if the
suggestion to take part in conversion practices
comes from a religious leader or family member.iv
Transgender, non-binary, and gender diverse people
in Aotearoa have higher exposure to conversion
practices.
People who have experienced conversion practices
have often faced, and will continue to face, abusive
relationships within their community, PTSD, major
traumatic incidents and a harmful accumulation of
smaller traumas.v
Conversion practices have been declared harmful in
Aotearoa and internationally by:
•
New Zealand Psychological Societyvi
•
the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of
Psychiatrists (RANZCP)vii
•
the NZ College of Clinical Psychologistsviii
•
the New Zealand Association of Counsellorsix and
other clinical peak bodies.
Further, leaders of Exodus International, once the
largest ‘ex-gay’ group formed in 1976 have publicly
acknowledged the harm their work caused, and
apologisedx, as have many of their former leaders and
member organisations. After admitting their programmes
did not change people they dissolved in 2013.
Survivors of conversion practices want
faith leaders to know that while it may
appear possible for some individuals
to temporarily suppress a part of who
they are, it cannot be sustained and is
always harmful in the end. This is why it
is important to engage with the evidence
and not rely on anecdotal reports of
people claiming to having successfully
‘changed’.
Conversion Practices Guidance for people working in religious communities