Background Report
Implementing and Developing the Law of Medical Errors:
the role of judicial and legislative bodies
Maen shihda Ideis1
The right to life and physical safety is one of the most fundamental inherent human
rights. For this reason, lawmakers have developed legislation which classifies any
actions that cause offence to this right as prohibited actions under national penal
codes as well as international declarations and conventions on human rights. Though
errors might occur in all professions and occupations, greater emphasis and focus is
placed on the errors that cause injury, impairment or sometimes death within the
health professions. In the countries where the physical safety of human beings is
respected, lawmakers who enact laws and the judiciary which applies these laws have
developed the provisions which criminalize negligence of precautionary measures by
healthcare and medical professionals. They have adopted new legal theories that
emphasize the sanctity of human life.
The Role of the Judicial System in Developing Medical Malpractice Laws
The enactment of laws regulating redress and compensation of victims of medical
malpractice cannot take place all at once, and can only take place gradually.
Sufficient time is needed, for example, to demonstrate the need for and then convince
people of the importance of such laws. It also will require juridical reviews and
advanced judicial applications whereby the judicial system adopts more modern
theories that contribute to the interpretation of the provisions of existing law, even if
is outdated.
Importantly, the victims of medical errors have not surrendered to the shortcomings of
these provisions, and quite to the contrary, they have urged the judiciary to further
develop the application of the effective provisions of law and to draft new and
efficient rules. The rules and the process itself might be modeled initially after those
of the French Council of State and then the French Court of Cassation in regard to
1
Maen shihda ideis is a member of the Palestinian Bar Association, and a major Legal Researcher at the
Independent Commission for Human Rights- palestine.
1