The UN Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights states that
governments must respect the rights of indigenous peoples to their culture and
heritage and to maintain and strengthen their spiritual relationship with ancestral
land indispensable to their cultural life, 58 including taking steps to return these lands
and territories.59
The Right to Participation
The Declaration also provides that the state must consult with indigenous peoples
in good faith and endeavour to obtain their consent on measures that may affect
them.60
The right of indigenous peoples to participation has been recognised as essential
to the realisation of their human rights. EMRIP has stated that the right: 61
…forms the fundamental basis for the enjoyment of the full range of human
rights…Without this foundational right, the human rights of indigenous
peoples, both collective and individual, cannot be fully enjoyed.
The Right to Free, Prior and Informed Consent
Central to the right to participation is the right of indigenous peoples to free, prior
and informed consent, one of the most important procedural principles in the
Declaration.62 It is also an issue central to the dispute at Ihumātao. The decisions
regarding the zoning of the Puketāpapa plot of land to a Special Housing Area and
the sale of the land to Fletcher Building were both overseen by public bodies.
The UN Committee on Economic Social and Cultural Rights has declared that
States “should respect the principle of free, prior and informed consent of
indigenous peoples in all matters covered by their specific rights”. 63
The principle of free, prior and informed consent operates as a safeguard for the
collective rights of indigenous peoples.64 It is also an aspect of the right of
indigenous peoples to self-determination. It therefore links closely to Te Tiriti
principle of tino rangatiratanga.
EMRIP has provided guidance on what is required of participation processes in
order to meet the minimum standards under the Declaration. EMRIP has found that
where disagreements arise within indigenous communities about whether free, prior
and informed consent has been achieved, such disagreements should be resolved
14