Institutional racism in the workplace
Most of the experiences people shared with us
related to interpersonal racism and discrimination.
However, institutional racism underpins these
experiences. This section discusses how structural
racism impacts Pacific people’s experiences of the
pay gap. This can include streaming in schools, career
advice, ideas about work and what it involves, the
separation of family and community life from working
life, and other aspects that might have influenced
people’s employment journey.
We have also drawn on research on structural
discrimination in this section. This research
reminds us that there are historical drivers for the
discrimination Pacific peoples experience:
New Zealand has benefitted from the colonisation
of the Pacific by creating, and continuing to
influence, education systems that limit Pacific
peoples to low-skilled jobs. The 1950s–1980s
saw New Zealand capitalise on this by ‘importing’
cheap Pacific labour which has contributed to the
Pacific Pay Gap over time. The cumulative effects
of occupational segregation, low pay, and little or
no opportunity to upskill have prevented social
mobility for Pacific peoples. Existing employment
schemes such as the Recognised Seasonal
Employer scheme continue this unfair labour
transaction. Despite significant evidence of Pacific
peoples experiencing racism in their jobs, there
remain few accessible avenues for addressing this.
One healthcare worker told us about their
experiences in higher education, and the limits the
institution tried to put on her. Although she had a
clear vision about what she wanted to study, the
university tried to direct her into what they thought
was best for her:
I went into the study, having to prove that I was
capable of doing university level study; which
is really weird, because even though I did the
Theology degree, I did other papers. You know, it
was just horrible, because they look at you - and
even one of the lecturers tried to convince me
not to do the addiction study, ‘cause they said,
‘Oh, you know, you might not be able to handle
the workload; the theory side of it.’ And I said,
‘Oh no-no, it’s really what I want. I have looked
at the counselling one, but it’s not what I want;
this is what I want.’ And you know, they did try to
talk me out of it. But yeah, it’s just really weird,
because you know I did a Theology degree, but a
lot of it was theory based; but they never saw it
as good enough for me to be able to do this other
undergraduate degree, for addiction. (T.003)
A Pacific researcher we spoke to said:
I’ve talked with teachers aka people who ‘mean
well’, who have talked about PI males having an
impact on the rugby field but not in education.
These are nice people who subconsciously
don’t realise what they are actually saying this.
Stereotypical comments. (R002)
They expanded on this theme to talk about how
stereotypes can limit Pacific peoples into one type of
employment, with ‘well-meaning’ encouragement into
vocational training:
Evidence from universities, six years after finishing
a bachelor’s degree your income will tend to
surpass the person with vocational training.
Nothing wrong with these jobs, but I am worried
about our people being given one option. Māori
historically were given only one option in NZ for
the longest time. (Researcher)
A Pacific healthcare worker spoke about the
dynamics of power in both the workplace and wider
industry:
I think that organisations like to say they are
diverse, but in reality, most of the positions of
power are taken by white men and women and
white employees know how to talk the same
language and access their white privilege that
way. I have over 20 years of experience and am
not recognised for this in my pay nor with regard
from my peers or manager, which I assume is
because I am vocal about racism in health against
Māori and Pasifika and take time off to care for
my family when they need me. I have only been
able to work from home since the pandemic and
am getting my work done well. However, there
is an expectation that I will return to the office.
(S105)
Voices of Pacific peoples
73