Cross-cultural communication issues
We heard about cultural differences and language barriers and how they impact Pacific
workers’ ability to request leave and raise concerns. Overall, many Pacific workers felt that
they were not being heard in the workplace.
The themes we heard from Pacific workers about
communication were:
• differing cultural norms
• language barriers
• employers’ role in communication
• Pacific workers supporting each other to
communicate.
Differing cultural norms
Due to their collective nature, most Pacific cultures
are similar in their communication style and share
similar cultural norms and values. These can often
be at odds with the dominant culture in a workplace.
Examples of practices that go against Pacific cultural
norms include talking about one’s achievements and
speaking against your elders or managers.
I believe our Pacific people are so humble and
will just get in there and do the job with no
complaints. We tend to shy away from asking for a
pay rise because I know it is not within our nature
to do so. Workplaces takes advantage of that. This
should be brought to light. (S324)
Language barriers
In addition to cultural differences, many Pacific
workers believed that language was a barrier to
gaining employment and pay rises. One construction
worker said that “language is a barrier – English is
my second language, I don’t have the right networks,
that’s why I think we don’t get the job” (T064).
Several Pacific workers shared their stories of how
employers respond to this language barrier. One
construction worker shared how he felt his employer
treated him due to his limited English capability:
A Pacific healthcare worker told us:
I think it was about your upbringing, always told
to be humble about your success, never be loud
and never talk good about yourself in case you
come across as being fiapoko – that’s just the way
it was. And of course that applied in my work life
and so I just worked really really hard and waited
for someone to see – rather than I did this and I
did that, you’d wait and sometimes the waiting just
went on and on … As soon as I found my voice and
some of my colleagues would still be in the same
mindframe that I was in quite a few years back and
just wait. It wasn’t that they couldn’t do the job, but
it was that they didn’t like promoting themselves
because … it was such an ingrained thing in them …
not to be as self-promoting. (T010)
As a result, Pacific workers in Aotearoa New Zealand
can operate in an environment with different
cultural norms from their own. Many Pacific workers
shared that they are often too shy to communicate,
especially on matters of pay. One person told us:
56
I think they take advantage of me because how
my English is not that good and my concerns
when raised with them is never taken seriously
until I get my union involved. (S200)
Employers’ role in communication
Pacific workers identified that positive and
reaffirming employer communication with employees
is vital for a healthy workplace – it helps people feel
safe to do their job and to exercise their rights. Many
of the stories we heard from Pacific workers across
the different sectors identify a lack of understanding
by employers of Pacific culture.
Several Pacific workers from the health and
agriculture sector shared their experiences when
they attempted to communicate with their employers
about their various concerns. Many Pacific workers
felt that their employer pretended to care but “was a
really difficult person to talk to and super busy and
unavailable” (S175).