employers with the tools to build a bridge between
themselves and their employees, which in turn can
develop accountability and consistent evaluation
that would see Pacific employees progress through
their workplace.364 Cultural competency training
often requires that employers meet their employees
halfway by making conscious efforts to understand
Pacific framings of knowledge production and
practice to improve workplace environments for both
the employer and employee.365 However, non-Pacific
employers rarely receive such training.366
For employers, it is strongly encouraged that
cultural competency training is provided from
Pacific perspectives.367 The literature argues that,
if employers understand Pacific values and the
importance of community and family, they will be
able to recognise the wider levels of responsibility
that Pacific workers occupy as providers for their
families beyond solely financial means.368 Cultivating
this deeper understanding would, in theory, enable
managers to improve employment policies in such a
way that would better account for Pacific perspectives
and further support their Pacific employees.369
Moreover, training non-Pacific employers in cultural
competency would help to challenge the deficit
narratives through which many employers appear
to interpret their Pacific workers. It is crucial that
employers understand that such narratives are
fragmented stories that fail to take into account
Pacific perspectives and render other valuable work
that they carry out within the community invisible.370
52
7.3.2 Limitations of cultural competency training
Diversity programmes like cultural competency
programmes do not guarantee the elimination of
racism in the workplace.371 This is evidenced in Pacific
workers’ observations that non-Pacific managers
display a lack of willingness to learn about and
engage with Pacific culture to support them in the
workplace.372 Pacific workers have reported being
frustrated by this, recognising that it impedes their
career progression and upholds negative stereotypes
about Pacific workers.373 Conversely, Pacific workers
place high value on having Pacific managers,
specifically because they understand Pacific culture
and how it affects Pacific workers in the workplace.374
Currently, many employers express a desire to
engage in cultural competence training but are
uncertain of where to begin and what to cover.375
As a result, ad hoc solutions are often put in place
by workplaces, but because they are not systemic,
they are often ineffective and poorly monitored,
producing few positive results.376 Many of these
approaches demand extra unpaid labour from
Pacific workers who are asked by their managers to
engage in extra work outside their job description
such as translation. Pacific workers are particularly
vulnerable to overworking due to a strong desire
to please superiors.377 Removing the onus to do
such work is critical to Pacific peoples’ workplace
success, and so, as the Ministry for Pacific Peoples
notes, implementing full wraparound and tailored
cultural competency training is necessary.378 The
364
Came et al., “Ethnic Pay Disparities,” 79.
365
Tunoa, Pacific Peoples’ Progression in the Labour Market, 35.
366
Equal Employment Opportunities Trust, Specifically Pacific, 39.
367
Tupou, “The Effect of the Glass Ceiling,” 96.
368
Equal Employment Opportunities Trust, Specifically Pacific, 43; Department of Labour, In Harm’s Way, 62.
369
Brougham, David, Jarrod Haar, and Maree Roche, A Kaupapa Māori Approach to Human Resource Management Practices in
Aotearoa Workplaces. Auckland, New Zealand Work Research Institute, 2020, 4; Auckland Co-design Lab, The Attitude Gap
Challenge, 96-97.
370
Ministry for Pacific Peoples, Pacific Aotearoa Lalanga Fou, 14; Vui-Talitu, Sara. “The Pacific’s Contribution to the NZ Economy.”
Radio New Zealand, November 29, 2019. https://www.rnz.co.nz/programmes/two-cents-worth/story/2018724446/thepacific-s-contribution-to-the-nz-economy.
371
Came et al., “Ethnic Pay Disparities,” 73.
372
Feilo, “Talanoa,” 52, 66; Auckland Co-design Lab, The Attitude Gap Challenge, 45, 66, 114.
373
Radio New Zealand, “Workplace Challenges for Pasifika Peoples.”
374
Equal Employment Opportunities Trust, Specifically Pacific, 29-31.
375
Auckland Co-design Lab, The Attitude Gap Challenge; Equal Employment Opportunities Trust, Specifically Pacific, 39-42.
376
Radio New Zealand, “Workplace Challenges for Pasifika Peoples”; Came et al., “Ethnic Pay Disparities,” 80.
377
Chen, National Culture, 43.
378
Ministry for Pacific Peoples, Pacific Employment Action Plan, 5.