Part I The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples: Background, content and implementation
Chapter 5:
The implementation of
the Declaration
KEY QUESTIONS
• What is the legal status of the Declaration?
• How does the Declaration relate to other international standards?
• What role can NHRIs play to advance the rights of indigenous peoples?
1. THE LEGAL STATUS OF THE DECLARATION
The Declaration was adopted through resolution 61/295 of the General Assembly. Unlike treaties or
conventions, resolutions do not per se create legally binding obligations on States. However:
… as a resolution adopted with the approval of an overwhelming majority of Member States, the
Declaration represents a commitment on the part of the United Nations and Member States to
its provisions, within the framework of the obligations established by the Charter of the United
Nations.151
The Declaration does not create new or special rights for indigenous peoples; rather, it elaborates
on existing human rights standards and articulates them as they apply to the particular situation of
indigenous peoples. Therefore, the Declaration illustrates the interdependent and indivisible nature of
international human rights norms and standards:
The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples represents an authoritative
common understanding, at the global level, of the minimum content of the rights of indigenous
peoples, upon a foundation of various sources of international human rights law. The product of a
protracted drafting process involving the demands voiced by indigenous peoples themselves, the
Declaration reflects and builds upon human rights norms of general applicability, as interpreted
and applied by United Nations and regional treaty bodies, as well as on the standards advanced
by ILO Convention No. 169 and other relevant instruments and processes.
The Declaration does not attempt to bestow indigenous peoples with a set of special or new
human rights, but rather provides a contextualized elaboration of general human rights principles
and rights as they relate to the specific historical, cultural and social circumstances of indigenous
peoples. The standards affirmed in the Declaration share an essentially remedial character,
seeking to redress the systemic obstacles and discrimination that indigenous peoples have faced
in their enjoyment of basic human rights. From this perspective, the standards of the Declaration
connect to existing State obligations under other human rights instruments.152
In a joint statement to celebrate the 2008 International Day of the World’s Indigenous People, the Acting
High Commissioner for Human Rights, Kyung-wha Kang, and the Special Rapporteur on the rights of
indigenous peoples, James Anaya, made this call for a political commitment to the Declaration:
151
A/64/338, para. 48.
152
A/HRC/9/9, paras. 85-86.
Chapter 5: The implementation of the Declaration | 37