130
Maranga Mai!
Many governments actively
opposed the Declaration and often
invented fatuous legal arguments
to justify their opposition. They
argued about whether Indigenous
Peoples were actually the kind of
“peoples” in whom rights might
vest in international law. The
governments of New Zealand,
Canada, the United States and
Australia regularly promoted those
sorts of arguments while claiming
to support the aspirations of
Indigenous Peoples.
Some argued that human rights
“only applied to individual rights
and not the collective nature of
rights as understood by Indigenous
Peoples”.
The costs to the indigenous people
participating in the working
groups were not just financial:
“Some Indigenous participants
were ‘disappeared’ by their
governments when they returned
home”.
In 2010, the [New Zealand]
government finally accepted the
Declaration but tried to diminish
its importance by saying it was
only an aspirational document.
“It’s disappointing and insultingly
offensive that some [people]
think the Declaration can just be
dismissed as unimportant and
divisive.” (Jackson, 2021c).
Race Relations Bill 1971: The
government introduced the
Race Relations Bill in 1971. The
aim of the original Bill was “to
disestablish the Māori Affairs
Department and other Māori
agencies, furthering the goals
of existing assimilation policies.
That was how the government
perceived its obligations to the UN.”
(Vincent O’Malley, Walley Penetito,
and Bruce Stirling 2010 cited in
O’Malley, V 2012).
Rangatiratanga: Submissions from
Māori argue that the Bill is the
Government’s attempt to distract
from Māori demands for legal
recognition of Te Tiriti. (O’Malley,
V 2012). In the Māori Council’s
manifesto, Pei Te Hurunui Jones
argues - “The Race Relations Act
(could) be a charter of human
relations at least as inspiring as
the first Race Relations Bill and
the Treaty of Waitangi. The Māori
people still seek legal recognition
of that Treaty, and a comparison
of its intentions with those of the
Bill under review would show that
the parallels are in fact close” (in
O’Malley, V 2012).
Race Relations Act 1971 outlawed
discrimination on the basis of race
and a Race Relations Conciliator
was appointed to investigate any
such allegations. This Act made it
“unlawful to discriminate against
any person by reason of his colour,
race, or ethnic or national origins”.
1972: New Zealand ratified the
Convention on the Elimination of
all Forms of Racial Discrimination
in (CERD). CERD 1(2) maintains
state parties should pursue the end
of racism through all appropriate
means and without delay (STIR &
NZPHA, 2021: 7).
Also in 1972, a female academic,
Ruth Ross, published an article in
the New Zealand Journal of History
in 1972 entitled ‘Te Tiriti o Waitangi:
Texts and Translations’. The
Waitangi Tribunal considered that
this article “stands as probably the
single most important interpretive
advance on the subject in modern
times”. Ross argued “the treaty
transaction was characterised by
confusion and undue haste. She
made the important observation
that sovereignty was translated
by Henry Williams in a different
way from his translation of ‘all
sovereign power and authority’ in
the declaration only a few years
previously. She concluded that the
Māori text was the true treaty and
that what mattered was how it had
been understood here, not what
the Colonial office had made of
the English text(s) in London. Her
rigorous empirical examination of
the original documents exposed
the unquestioning acceptance
of myths about the treaty by an
earlier generation of scholars. And
she left her contemporaries with
the uncomfortable realisation that
a reliance on what was said in the
English text alone was no longer
intellectually honest” (Waitangi
Tribunal, 2014, p410).
1973: the Race Relations
Conciliator denies that racist
intent exists in New Zealand: “The
expression ‘white racism’ … [has]
been used with reference to the
NZ scene. I think this is a mistake. I
think there is no or little racist intent
in NZ either among the citizens, or
in the system, or in the way of life.
I do not think a citizen can prove
racial discrimination” (Guy Powles,
the first Race Relations Conciliator,
1973 cited in Salient 1974: 13).
1974: MOOHR recommends
the Race Relations Conciliator
implement the CERD (O’Malley, 2012).
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents