37
Human Rights Commission
Unconscious, implicit and latent bias
Unconscious, implicit, or latent bias reflects the
tendency of racists to unknowingly perceive ‘others’
in stereotypical ways (Blank, Houkamau & Kingi,
2016, p. 13; Houkamau, 2016, pp. 125–6). Māori suffer
disproportionately from implicit bias (Houkamau,
Stronge, & Sibley, 2017: p. 74) because the negative
and racist attitudes sown during colonisation towards
Māori are now deeply entrenched in New Zealand
(Blank et al, 2016, p. 13).
The assumptions underpinning latent bias can
express as overt derogatory abuse like ‘Māori bastard’
and ‘nigger’. The notorious racist Philip Arps refers to
Māori as ‘shit skins’ (Taonui, 2021). More commonly,
the assumptions will remain unspoken, leaving the
prejudice detectable only by observation of their
actions and impacts. This can include omissions like
a lack of effort to learn how to pronounce the name
of someone from another cultural group, casual
assumptions about the occupation of another person
based on their perceived race, or declining
an application to rent a property because someone
is Māori (Taonui 2021). Another common example
is when Māori are followed or receive unfair
treatment in shops, based on the racial assumption
they are criminal and potential shoplifters (Smith et
al, 2021, p. 10).
While bias can be unconscious, the over-emphasis
on unconscious bias in Pākehā society becomes
a way to avoid discussing racism and its impacts
upon Māori, and the central role of white supremacy
and colonisation in the social production of
racist outcomes (see Cooper and Davis, 2013).
As Dr Jackson described:
The police like the term ‘unconscious bias’ because
it is less threatening than the ‘r-word’. But that
does not address the racism that underpins the
whole police structure, that underpins a colonising
society. So there’s no way the police will want to
talk about racism because it goes to the very base
of a colonising state (Jackson, 2021a).
This tendency is captured in a recent media article:
“Police are investigating whether they have an
unconscious bias against Māori, but won’t say it is an
inquiry into racism” (Radio New Zealand, 2021a).
The existence and expression of unconscious bias
is a result of societal racism toward Māori:
Unconscious bias cannot be separated from the
broader racism it services. So, when we ask the
question, ‘Why is someone unconsciously biased
against Māori’? it is because society is based on
racism directed against Māori. If we weren’t a
race-based society, there would be no
unconscious bias against Māori (Jackson, 2021a).
Structural, institutional and
systemic racism
Personal prejudice, inter-personal racism and
institutional racism are related. However, an
important distinction needs to be made between
personal prejudice and racism, and institutional,
structural and systemic racism (ACORD, 1986, p. 7,
Workman, 2011, p. 7).
When members of a dominant group, holding
prejudiced assumptions, monopolise government
legislation and policy, and decision-making in
housing, education, health, justice, welfare and other
public and private sector organisations, the result is
structural and institutional racism (Taonui, 2021).
This is because the way that relationships are
structured privileges white norms (ACORD, 1986, p.
7) and imposes a dominant European worldview
on society (Came and McCreanor, 2015, p. 2).
This entrenches a pattern of differential access
to opportunities, resources and state power that
advantages Pākehā while disadvantaging Māori
(Came and McCreanor, 2015, p. 2; Department of
Social Welfare, 1985, p. 3). In this manner, white
privilege perpetuates disparities and inequities
experienced by Māori (ACORD, 1986, p. 7).
Institutional racism is not always obvious because
the underlying prejudice hides behind complex rules,
practices, policies and decision-making processes.
These are framed, written and confirmed in the
absence of Māori. The effects of institutional racism
are cumulative, intergenerational and profoundly
more damaging than interpersonal racism (see
ACORD, 1986, p. 7).
Māori in Aotearoa live under a constitutional and
legal structure that is foreign to them and which
derives from England (Charters, 2009). Tikanga