134
Maranga Mai!
Came, 2012).
2006: The Ministry of Health
directed all district health
boards to no longer make
any reference to the Treaty in
any policy, actions, plans or
contracts, due to the government’s
concern about backlash from
the general public.
Justice
1987: Moana Jackson releases
his report on the criminal justice
system He Whaipaanga Hou.
The well-recognised fact that
Māori are overrepresented in
criminal justice is directly linked
to colonisation, racism and
white supremacy. This report
was pivotal in highlighting Māori
experiences of institutional racism
in criminal justice. As a system
built on “monocultural attitudes”, it
actively oppressed Māori notions
of justice, and continues to alienate
Māori therein through an overtly
Eurocentric values base. Despite
decades of evidence of Māori
overrepresentation in the Criminal
Justice system
In 2010 the Special Rapporteur
could not “help but note the
extreme disadvantage in the social
and economic conditions of Māori
people, which are dramatically
manifested in the continued
and persistent high levels of
incarceration of Māori individuals.
These troubling conditions
undoubtedly result from the
historical and ongoing denial of
the human rights of Māori, which
must continue to be addressed
as a matter of upmost priority”
(Anaya, J. 2010:3)
In 2019, we saw the highest-ever
number of Māori being caught
in the justice pipeline which is
an effect of a history of selfdetermination undermined, for the
dispossession of Māori lands and
ways of being (Te Uepū Hāpai i
te Ora, Safe and Effective Justice
Advisory Group, 2019).
2005: United Nations Committee
on the Elimination of Racial
Discrimination determined that
“… the [2004 Foreshore and
Seabed] legislation appears to the
Committee, on balance, to contain
discriminatory aspects against …
Māori customary titles over the
foreshore and seabed”.
Welfare
1988: the report Puao-Te-Ata-Tu
is released. Initially focused on
state care and protection of Māori
children, it states “the issues facing
Māori resulted from failing systems
of state provision underpinned by
a broader context of colonisation,
racism and structural inequity”. It
recommended significant changes
to organisational policy, planning
and service delivery.
These messages have been
repeated for over three decades
now: without exception, every
major review focused on issues of
critical importance for Māori has
identified profoundly failing state
sector systems, stressing an urgent
need for bold transformational
change. Boulton, A., Levy, M.,
Cvitanovic, L., (Dec 2020).
In 2020 the Waitangi Tribunal
released its findings on Oranga
Tamariki (Child, Youth and Family,
renamed). It acknowledged the
Crown’s failure to implement the
recommendations of Puao-TeAta-Tu. “The Waitangi Tribunal
has called on the Government
to step back from intruding into
Māori communities, ruling the
care of Māori children by Oranga
Tamariki has breached the Treaty
of Waitangi”.
“It is important to understand
that the need for change and
the process of transformation we
recommend has nothing to do with
separatism and everything to do
with realising the Treaty promise,
that two peoples may coexist
harmoniously,” the tribunal said.
(Thomas Manch, Apr 30 2021).
In 2021, Oranga Tamariki, is
again criticised:
“It is self-centred and constantly
looks to itself for answers. Its
current systems are weak,
disconnected and unfit for the
population of tamariki it serves,
and there is no strategy to partner
with Māori and the community”
(Tukaki, M. Glavish, N., Solomon,
M. and Pakura, S., 2021, p10).
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents