Furthermore, another 7,315.47 hectares of Orang Asli lands that were
approved for gazetting, was not only never gazetted but their ‘approved’
status was eventually revoked. Thus, from 1990 to 2003, at least 8,760.28
hectares of recognized Orang Asli lands had their status retracted.
In the same period, nevertheless, there was an increase of applications
for Orang Asli reserves, from 67,019.46 hectares in 1990 to 79,715.53
hectare in 2003. It should be noted however that the majority of these
new applications for gazetting were to replace Orang Asli lands that were
degazetted for development projects (such as the KLIA and Selangor Dam
projects) or for new resettlement schemes. Even so, the status of these
lands is that of mere ‘applications’. They do not have the legal weight of the
second category (‘approved for gazetting but not gazetted yet’) which, it
should be added, in itself was also not a good enough category to secure
Orang Asli lands.
As noted by the judges in the High Court and Court of Appeal judgments in
the Sagong Tasi case, the main problems facing the Orang Asli with regard
to their customary lands is one in which the government has failed in its
statutory duty to protect Orang Asli lands from encroachment, exploitation
and appropriation by others (including the government itself). As a result
of the state and federal governments’ neglect in both under-gazetting and
not gazetting areas which they knew were inhabited by the Orang Asli, the
latter’s rights in the land were placed in serious jeopardy.
2.1.2
Problems related to Relocation & Resettlement
As a consequence of not being accorded rights to their lands, whole
Orang Asli communities are often subject to relocation and resettlement
to make way for a development project of a public or private nature. The
presumption is that these areas are often chosen because such lands are
deemed to be state land or at best, gazetted Orang Asli reserves where
little by way of compensation need to be forked out.
ORANG ASLI – RIGHTS, PROBLEMS & SOLUTIONS
25