Appendix 1: Literature review
Appendices
The design of the surveys was informed
by a literature review that included the
existing literature on child mental health and
wellbeing in Australia, both pre-pandemic and
contemporary, and the systems and conditions
that support positive mental health and
wellbeing. It also included relevant government
policies to understand the government decisions
about pandemic-related restrictions.
In this review, literature within the last decade
was prioritised. A snowballing strategy was
used, where the reference lists of large articles
and reports were reviewed to identify additional
relevant sources.
It is known that young people’s wellbeing is
influenced by culture, social norms and media.
Therefore, research from Australia and other
developed western nations with similar cultural
backgrounds was prioritised. In consideration of
this mixed methods approach, both qualitative
and quantitative research was explored.
The search scope included considerable ‘grey’
literature (for example, media reports or opinion
pieces). Given the dynamic and changing
issues that emerged throughout the pandemic,
publication and reporting of the state of affairs
has happened through the media rather than
peer-reviewed sources. Only research published
in English was considered in this review.
There is substantial variation, and overlap,
of terminology within the literature base.
Definitional differences plague accurate
reporting of mental health issues and poor
wellbeing outcomes for children and young
people. For the purposes of this report, ‘mental
health and wellbeing’ is used to refer to the
range of mental health issues facing children.
Some statistics on the pervasiveness of mental
health conditions relate to young children,
whereas others explore cohorts up to 25 years
old. Where possible, this is made clear in the
different statistics reported.
130 |
1.1 What was the state of
children and young people’s
mental health and wellbeing
pre‑pandemic?
A downward trend in relation to children’s
mental health was evident well before the
pandemic hit.64 For example, Australia ranked
35 out of 38 for mental wellbeing in a global
UNICEF report with data collected prior to the
pandemic.65
There have been ongoing reports of declining
adolescent emotional wellbeing, particularly
among girls.66 There has been a sustained rise
in the prevalence of mental health issues for
young people aged 12–17 years, with a greater
increase for girls.67
The second and most recent Australian Child
and Adolescent Survey of Mental Health and
Wellbeing was conducted in 2013–14 with over
6,300 families with children aged 4–17 years.68
Parents and carers completed a survey, while
children aged 11 years and older completed
their own survey. These results were compared
with the 1998 National Survey of Mental Health
and Wellbeing (based only on parent/carer
reporting). This comparison showed no change
in depressive disorders between 1998 and
2013–14 for children aged 6–11 years. However,
the prevalence of major depressive disorders
for children aged 12–17 increased from 2.9% to
5%. According to this 2013–14 data, the most
common conditions for girls was anxiety, and
attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD)
for boys.69 The report suggested one in seven
children aged between 4 and 17 experience
mental health issues.
Survey data of 4,065 children and young people
aged between 12 and 25 years collected by
headspace in 2018 showed one-third (32%) of
participating Australian children and young
people were experiencing psychological
distress.70
‘Mental health shapes my life’: COVID-19 & kids’ wellbeing • 2022 | 131