सव
भव तु सिखनः
ु
Annual Report 2022-23
The department further emphasised that there was no
pre-scheduled maintenance work on the day of the
incident. It was an unforeseen accident, and the departmental staff could not be held responsible. Addi onally,
an internal inquiry was conducted, which concluded that
the incident was indeed accidental. In addi on to
providing monetary compensa on of rupees ten lakh to
the NoK of the deceased, the Delhi Jal Board also
extended government job offers to the deceased family
members on compensatory grounds to support their
long-term needs.
In response to these ac ons, the Commission reviewed
the report and highlighted the need for Delhi Jal Board to
ensure compliance with the direc ves issued by the
Commission in the form of an Advisory dated 24 September 2021. This advisory focused on the protec on of
human rights for individuals engaged in hazardous
cleaning. With these direc ons and ac ons taken into
account, the case was officially closed.
4.) Two Safai Karmacharies succumbed to poisonous
gases while cleaning the man-hole and payment of
compensa on
Case No.119/10/1/2020
The Commission received a complaint from the Na onal
Convener, Safai Karmachari Andolan, alleging that three
Safai Karmacharies were called to clean a chamber/manhole in the premises of Sri. SSBS Jain Sangh Trust
on Infantry Road, Bengaluru. They were asked to enter
inside the manhole. During the cleaning, two of them
succumbed to poisonous gases and lost their lives on 25
January 2020.
Pursuant to the direc ons of the Commission, Commissioner of Police, Bengaluru City vide a communica on
dated 08 October 2020 submi ed the report of DCP East
Division, Bengaluru City, along with enquiry report of ACP
Pulikeshi Nagar Sub- division, Bengaluru City, which
revealed t h at t wo p e rs o n s died. One belonged to the
Scheduled Caste. Police registered FIR vide Case Crime
No. 13/2020 u/s 304/338 r/w 34 IPC and 3(1)(J) SC/ST Act
and Sec on 7 / 8 / 9 Prohibi on of Employment as Manual
Scavengers and their Rehabilita on Act, 2013. During
inves ga on, Sec ons 7/8/9 of Prohibi on of Manual
Scavengers and their Rehabilita on Act 2013 were le out
because of non- availability of evidence and added
Sec on 87/88 of Juvenile Jus ce Act-2015. The Police
68
arrested four accused and a er inves ga on, a charge
sheet was filed in the court. A copy of FIR, postmortem
report and other connected documents had been
submi ed to Social Welfare Department to facilitate the
compensa on process.
Vide proceedings dated 16 January 2021, the Commission
issued direc on to the Deputy Commissioner, Bengaluru,
Karnataka, to submit the proof of payment of compensaon within four weeks. Meanwhile, the Commission
received the ac on taken report dated 21 September
2020 from the Jt. Labour Commissioner informing the
facts of the case and submi ed that regarding compensaon, the labour office had no jurisdic on.
Pursuant to the direc ons issued by the Commission
dated 02 February 2022, a le er was received from the
Joint Director, Social Welfare Department, Bengaluru
Urban District, dated 08 March 2022 along with the report
of Secretary, Karnataka State Commission for Safai
Karmacharis, Bengaluru, and with other relevant papers.
The report reveals that the compensa on amount to the
dependent has been paid by the District Social Welfare
Department. The proof of payment was submi ed. Thus,
a er perusal of the report, it was clear that the direc on
issued by the Commission had been complied and
compensa on amount had been paid to the NoK of the
deceased. The proof of payment had been submi ed by
the authority. Nothing remains to proceed further in the
ma er. The report was taken on record and the case was
closed.
5.) Fatal Guter Fall in Karawal Nagar, Delhi, due to the
negligence of the public authori es.
(Case No: 2649/30/5/2020)
On 08 June 2020, the Commission received a no fica on
alleging the death of a young student residing in Karawal
Nagar, Delhi, on 6 June 2020. It was alleged that his
demise occurred due to a fall into a gu er, a ributable to
the negligence of the relevant department responsible for
construc ng the wall surrounding the gu er.
Upon receipt of this informa on, the Commission
ini ated an inquiry and directed the Deputy Commissioner of Police, Northeast, Delhi, and the Commissioner
of the East Delhi Municipal Corpora on, Delhi, to provide
an ac on taken report. In response, the Inves ga on
Division of NHRC assembled a team to conduct a spot
Chapter 7 - Thematic Areas