Status
The Committee recommended that “the State party should
7.
incorporate into the Criminal Act a definition of torture that includes the
mental and psychological aspects of torture” in its concluding observations
on the combined third to fifth periodic reports of the Republic of Korea in
2017.
In addition, the U.N. Human Rights Committee (“UNHRC”)
8.
concerned that “the State party’s criminal legislation does not adequately
ensure that acts covered by the internationally-accepted definition of torture
are fully criminalized, especially mental torture” in its concluding
observations on the forth periodic report of the Republic of Korea.
9.
In response, the Korean government made its position that the article
1251 of Criminal Act stipulates penalizing “acts of violence or cruelty”, and
acts of cruelty includes mental torture. It added that amendment of Criminal
Act is not necessary to incorporate definition of torture.
10.
The Supreme Court ruled that cruel act in Article 273 of Criminal Act
involves not only physical pain but also mental discrimination to
abandonment (Supreme Court Decision 2000Do233 Decided April 25, 2000),
and the acts of cruelty (ibid., art. 125) is broader than cruelty (ibid., art. 273)
and is equivalent to cruel act (ibid., art. 277)2 under general interpretation of
1 A person who, in performing or assisting in activities concerning judgment, prosecution, police or
other functions involving the restraint of the human body, commits an act of violence or cruelty
against a criminal suspect or against another person while in the performance of his/her duties,
shall be punished by imprisonment for not more than five years and suspension of qualifications
for not more than ten years.
2 A person who illegally arrests or confines another, thereby treating that person cruelly, shall
6