Chapter 2 - Report of the Complaints, Monitoring and Inquiries Group
Lunch is being prepared at one of the Immigration detention centres
3.
Treatment of detainees and rehabilitation programmes
With the rise in recidivism, higher priority should be placed on the role of rehabilitation
programmes in prison. During one visit, the Commission was informed that the prison
is divided into categories covering sexual offences, drug cases and criminal offences, for
example. This allows the authorities to focus the rehabilitation programmes to the needs
of each group of prisoners. Subject to availability and term to be served, prisoners are also
placed in a prison that is as close as possible to their homes. This facilitates family visits,
thereby enhancing the rehabilitation process.
However, it was observed that due to the shortage of human resources – especially of
civilian staff – some prisons are unable to implement proper rehabilitation programmes.
This should be dealt with as soon as possible.
In line with its motto ‘Human Rights for All’, the Commission took the initiative to look into
the rights and welfare of personnel at all detention centres. It was found that they continue
to be exposed to difficult working conditions and risk being exposed to infectious disease like
tuberculosis. Most of them also do not have proper working facilities.
4. CHILDREN IN IMMIGRATION DETENTION CENTRES
(a) Roundtable Discussion
In continuation of a campaign launched in April 2012 to end Immigration detention of children,
the Commission organised a Roundtable Discussion (RTD) on 12 November. The objectives were
to sustain awareness of the issue and to seek effective action. It was organised in cooperation
with the SUKA Society and the International Detention Coalition (IDC). Participants comprised
Immigration officers including commandants of detention centres, representatives of the Home
Ministry, the Ministry of Women, Family and Community Development, the Welfare Department,
and UNHCR, International Committee of the Red Cross, Voices of Children and a member of the
UN Committee on CRC.
The IDC and International Social Services Hong Kong shared their experiences and expertise on
alternatives to the detention of children. The participants unanimously agreed that there should
be such alternatives and that children – especially those who are unaccompanied – should not
51