Chapter 2 - Report of the Complaints, Monitoring and Inquiries Group
Table 3: Visits to Detention Centres, 2013
PLACES OF DETENTION
PERIODIC VISITS
CASE-BASED VISITS
Prisons
8
4
Immigration detention centres
6
2
Police lock-ups
8
2
TOTAL
22
8
The Commission carries out periodic visits to monitor the physical state of a detention centre,
its facilities, rehabilitation programmes, treatment, diet and healthcare provisions and the wellbeing of personnel. Case-based visits are carried out when complaints are received, and focus
on issues brought to the Commission’s attention.
The Commission’s Recommendations
The situation in detention centres generally met the minimum standards. However, there is
room for improvement.
1.
Healthcare and treatment for sick prisoners/detainees
The Commission observed that prisons, especially old ones, are not sufficiently equipped
with facilities or resources to cater to the minimum needs and healthcare of detainees.
While there is a post for a medical assistant at Immigration detention centres, it has not
been filled. The Commission believes that there should be at least one medical personnel
at any detention centre as this will not only be beneficial to detainees, but also to staff. The
Commission is aware of a shortage of basic medicines because several detention centres
are overcrowded.
The Commission received several complaints that ill detainees did not receive proper
treatment. It was further told that there is no special diet for detainees/prisoners with
diabetes and the only option is to replace the rice with white bread. The Commission feels
that the detainees/prisoners need to be examined by the medical officer, who should
then advise the administrator on the provision of appropriate meals. The administrator
should also seek guidance from the Ministry of Health on the right nutrition or diet for sick
detainees/prisoners.
2.
50
Budget allocation for meals
The Commission has found that the budget allocation for meals varies from one detention
centre to another and that, at times, the amount appears to be too low. For example,
one Immigration detention centre only had a budget of RM4.50 per person per day –
which worked out to RM0.70 for breakfast, RM1.90 for lunch and RM1.90 for dinner. The
Commission was informed that the tender for supply of meals is awarded by the Home
Ministry. The Commission hopes that this allocation will be revised from time to time.