•
the lack of ratification and full implementation of the ICESCR in some states.179
The future
To combat these difficulties, UNESCO advocates for countries to introduce constitutionally
guaranteed provisions setting out the right to education.180 This would establish a concrete
right for legislative and executive actions to be measured against and also allow victims of
alleged breaches to bring those breaches before a constitutional court.181 Further, it is difficult
to monitor and enforce obligations without legislation.
The consequences of making
economic, social and cultural rights an enforceable part of a constitution are that human rights
norms aimed at seeking social or distributive justice will find a degree of permanence, and
access to justice will increase.182
States must develop and modernise national laws, promote the right to education, educate the
general public about the available remedies, and also educate judges on the justiciability of
the right, as these are critical elements of strengthening the right to education. Furthermore,
the justiciability of the right to education is inseparable from the question of its enforceability
and the existence of adequate remedies.183
The judiciary can also play a key role in strengthening the right to education. Increasingly,
judges have been taking advantage of the jurisprudence of other jurisdictions to support the
justiciability of the right to education.184 This solidarity will be instrumental in raising the
awareness of governments and creating international pressure for the need to make this right
fully justiciable. It may also be desirable for the judiciary to take into account guidance
179
United Nations “Workshop for Judges on the Justiciability of Economic, Social and cultural Rights
in South Asia – Statement of Conclusions” (18 November 2001) Press Release, n 11.
180
UNESCO(CR)/ECOSOC(CESCR) Joint Expert Group on the Monitoring of the Right to Education
Justiciability of the Right to Education 175 EX/28 12-13 May 2006, at para 8.
181
UNESCO(CR)/ECOSOC(CESCR) Joint Expert Group on the Monitoring of the Right to Education
Justiciability of the Right to Education 175 EX/28 12-13 May 2006, at para 8.
182
Dr Justice D Y Chandrachud “Bridging the Chasm between Human Rights’ Doctrine and
Enforcement: The Role and Remedies for Judicial Institutions” www.interights.org/doc/Fiji%20Colloq
uium%2006/paper1%20Fiji.doc (last accessed 27 March 2007) at 5 – 6.
183
United Nations Workshop for Judges on the Justiciability of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
in South Asia, New Delhi, 17 - 18 November 2001 Statement of Conclusions, http://www.unhchr.ch/hu
ricane/huricane.nsf/(Symbol)/OHCHR.STM.01.77.En?OpenDocument (last accessed 26 March 2007)
at para 7.
184
United Nations Workshop for Judges on the Justiciability of Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
in South Asia, New Delhi, Opening Address by Ms Mary Robinson High Commissioner for Human
Rights, 17 November 2001 http://www.unhchr.ch/huricane/huricane.nsf/view01/5962093D418A5BCF
C1256B74003E0080?opendocument (last accessed 24 March 2007) at 2.
77