minorities, including homosexuals, were allowed to express their gender identity and sexual
orientation. The provision on the punishment of homosexuality441) was also revised to
punish only forced same-sex intercourse, but in 2017, all references to same-sex intercourse
were deleted.
With this ruling by the Supreme Court, the statutory provisions in this case do not apply to
sexual acts, including anal sex between male soldiers, in a private space with the consent of
the parties involved, but there is room for punishment by treating them differently from
sexual acts between the opposite sex if two people mutually agree to engage in sexual acts,
such as anal sex, in the public, business realm or similar situations. The public indecency
(Article 245) under the Criminal Act, the desertion from military service (Article 30), and
the neglect of duty (Article 35) under the Military Criminal Act already exist, and other
means to establish discipline while restricting the fundamental rights less, such as
disciplinary actions, are available. However, this provision excessively violates individual
human rights by criminalizing anal sex between consenting soldiers.
Since Korea applies the conscription system, sexual minorities, such as transgender,
intersex, and non-binary people whose legal gender at birth is male, are also subjected to
compulsory military service. Moreover, there will definitely be sexual minorities among
officers and noncommissioned officers serving in the military. Nevertheless, male
homosexuals in the military have long been ostracized. In 2009, the Ministry of National
Defense established the ‘Unit Management Directives’ to prohibit discrimination on the
basis of homosexuality, and advocated a non-discriminatory military culture for the sexual
minorities, but in practice, there is significant lack of related policies, guidelines, and
protection systems within the military. With this Supreme Court decision, there is a need to
abolish Article 92-6 of the Military Criminal Act, which has unfairly restricted the basic
human rights of LGBTI people in the military, and establish conditions for LGBTI people to
fulfill their national defense duties without discrimination and serve in the military.
441) Art. 125. 10 U. S. C. § 925.
186
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات