PASTOR RAYMOND KOH
on evidence which is probably true and which does not need to be proved to be
beyond reasonable doubt.
Burden of Proof in Cases of Enforced Disappearance
71.
On the burden of proof, that is, on whose shoulders lie the burden of proving the
case, the approach taken in internaonal human rights cases on enforced
disappearances, is illustrave to show that the burden of proof lies on the State
itself. This was held by various courts as follows:
71.1.
Bamaca-Velasquez v Guatemala17, the Inter-American Court of Human
Rights held as follows:
"As this Court has oen repeated, in cases of forced
disappearance, the State's defense cannot rely on the
impossibility of the plainff to present evidence in the
proceedings since, in such cases, it is the State that controls the
means to clarify the facts that have occurred in its jurisdicon
and, therefore, in pracce, it is necessary to rely on the
cooperaon of the State itself in order to obtain the required
evidence.
...In cases such as forced disappearance - and others... - the State
has beer possibilies of assuming the funcon of proving what
it denies, than the individual to prove what he affirms”
71.2.
Godinez Cruz v Honduras 18, the Inter-American Court of Human Rights
held:
“141. In contrast to domesc criminal law, in proceedings to
determine human rights violaons the State cannot rely on the
defense that the complainant has failed to present evidence when
it cannot be obtained without the State's cooperaon.
142. The State controls the means to verify acts occurring within
its territory. Although the Commission has invesgatory powers,
it cannot exercise them within a State's jurisdicon unless it has
the cooperaon of that State.”19
17
IACHR Series C No 70 (Official Citaon); [2000] IACHR 7 (Other Reference); IHRL 1453 (IACHR 2000) (OUP reference);
IACHR Series C No 91 (Official Citaon); [2002] IACHR 1 (Other Reference); IHRL 1474 (IACHR 2002) (OUP reference)
18
IACHR Series C no 10 (Official Citaon); IHRL 1391 (IACHR 1990) (OUP reference)
19
See also Velasquez-Rodriguez v Honduras (IACtHR, 1988).
26
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات