Foreword
The following report has been produced by Dr Sharon Shalev, who has completed
an independent review of seclusion and restraint practices in a number of New
Zealand detention settings.
Dr Shalev is an international expert in the field of solitary confinement and
seclusion. She is a research associate at the Centre for Criminology at the
University of Oxford and a Fellow of the Mannheim Centre for Criminology at the
London School of Economics and Political Science. She completed her doctorate
on American Supermax Prisons, is the author of the influential Sourcebook on
Solitary Confinementi and has recently completed a comprehensive study of
segregation units and close supervision centers in England and Wales.ii
Dr Shalev is well qualified to comment on the practices in place in our country.
We are very grateful to her for accepting the commission to undertake this work
and for providing an independent perspective on New Zealand practice. This
report sets out her observations and recommendations based on her visits to
selected New Zealand detention facilities during October and November 2016.
The views expressed by Dr Shalev do not necessarily represent those of the
Human Rights Commission or the individual National Preventive Mechanism
partners. However, they provide an important catalyst for further discussion and
action.
Dr Shalev’s report highlights a number of serious issues. These include:
• A high use of solitary confinement and restraint
• Overrepresentation of ethnic minority groups in solitary confinement and
restraint incidents
i
http://www.solitaryconfinement.org/sourcebook
ii
Deep Custody: the use of segregation and close supervision centres in England and Wales (2015)
(http://solitaryconfinement.org/uploads/DeepCustodyShalevAndEdgar.pdf)
3