and suicide, which are anyway higher in prison than they are in the general
population, are even higher in solitary confinement units.7
If solitary confinement can be damaging to those with no previous history
of mental health issues, individuals with pre-existing mental illness are at a
particularly high risk of worsening psychiatric problems as a result of their
isolation.8 Children and young people are also particularly vulnerable to the
damaging effects of solitary confinement, as they are still in the process of
developing physically, mentally and socially, and solitary confinement effectively
‘freezes’ their development.9
Not everyone will experience solitary confinement in the same way. Individual
responses to the stresses of solitary confinement vary, “depending on the premorbid adjustment of the individual and the context, length and conditions of
confinement. The experience of previous trauma will render the person more
vulnerable, as will the involuntary nature of his/her solitary confinement and
confinement that persists over a sustained period of time. Initial acute reactions
may be followed by chronic symptoms if the regime of solitary confinement
persists”.10 Some of these reactions may subside once the person is no
longer in solitary confinement, but some individuals will carry with them the
damage caused by solitary confinement long after their release from solitary
confinement. The damaging effects of solitary confinement are therefore best
mitigated by avoiding the placement of people in isolation altogether. Where
people are held in solitary confinement, this should be limited to a short and
pre-defined time, during which they should be housed in decent conditions,
have access to meaningful human contact and to purposeful activities, and be
able to exercise some personal autonomy.
Following three decades of what seemed like an unstoppable expansion in the
use of solitary confinement, especially in the United States, in recent years the
practice has been attracting increasing international attention. Human Rights
and professional bodies, both international and regional, begun focusing their
attention on its uses and consequences, seeking ways to minimise and better
7
Kaba, Fatos et al (2014) Solitary Confinement and Risk of Self-Harm Among Jail Inmates. American Journal
of Public Health 104.3 (2014): 442–447; Fazel S et al. (2011) Prison suicides in 12 countries: an ecological
study of 861 suicides during 2003–2007. Social Psychiatry Psychiatric Epidemiology, 46:191–195.
8
United Nations General Assembly, Report of the Special Rapporteur on Torture A/HRC/22/53 1 February
2013, par. 67-68. See also: Kupers T. (1999) Prison madness: the mental health crisis behind bars and what
we must do about it. San Francisco: Jossey Bass; Reid W.H. (2000) Offenders with special needs. Journal of
Psychiatric Practice, 6(5):280–283.
9
American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) (2013) Alone and Afraid: Children Held in Solitary Confinement and
Isolation in Juvenile Detention and Correctional Facilities. ACLU: Washington DC.
10 Shalev, S. (2014). ‘Solitary Confinement as a Prison Health Issue’. In: Enggist, S., Moller, L., Galea, G. and Udsen,
C., (Eds.) Prisons and Health: a World Health Organisation (WHO) guide to the essentials in prison health
(2nd edition), Copenhagen: WHO Regional Office Europe. pp27-35.
18