Australian Human Rights Commission
Respect at Uni Interim Report
December 2024
This touted reduction in incidents is just as much a product of the
reduction in Jewish students who feel comfortable and safe attending their
campuses as it is a diminishment in the sentiment that we're seeing. 55
The degree to which antisemitism is distinct from other forms of racism has been
raised with the Commission, with views expressed that a tailored approach is
required to address antisemitism. Some Jewish groups have suggested to the
Commission that antisemitism can be effectively addressed through
comprehensive efforts to address all forms of racism more broadly.
The next phase of the Study will consider this through fieldwork and consultation
with stakeholders.
(c)
Muslim, Arab and Palestinian staff and students
Muslim, Arab and Palestinian communities are not homogenous and are
frequently conflated. Meeting with Muslim and Arab student groups has been
challenging in the Commission’s initial consultation phase because there are no
central organisations that represent these students or academics. The Study
team plans to connect with Muslim and Arab student associations at universities
in early 2025 to begin consultations. However, initial consultations highlighted
that political and media rhetoric often ‘others’ Muslims, Arabs and Palestinians
and links them with terrorism, leading to feelings of exclusion, dehumanisation
and isolation.
The Commission has heard from Palestinian representatives that Palestinian
students are scared to speak up about racist experiences, with concern about
academic and other ramifications, such as doxxing. Some of these organisations
have received student reports that prayer rooms had been closed on campus.
Students had also reported being required by staff to leave lectures and tutorials
because their computers or notebooks had stickers of the Palestinian flag.
Another student was told they could not wear their keffiyeh at a graduation
ceremony. The Commission heard that Palestinian and Arab academic staff had
received hate mail, death threats and experienced abuse on campus.
Consultations also revealed perceptions of differential treatment of
Islamophobia, anti-Arab and anti-Palestinian incidents, compared to
antisemitism. Some felt that while antisemitism resulted in harsh consequences,
Islamophobia, Anti-Arab and anti-Palestinian incidents were treated less
seriously.
These experiences are similar to previous consultations conducted by the
Commission. The Sharing the Stories of Australian Muslims 56 report found that
39