aspects. In initial consultations, the Commission was told that antisemitism is a
specific, distinct form of racism embedded in centuries of vilification and
persecution. The Commission also heard that Islamophobia stereotypes all
Muslims as terrorists while also seriously endangering individuals who ‘look
Muslim’. Additionally, racism has a specific and often disproportionate impact on
women, young people, people with disability and those living in regional areas of
Australia.
Adding to this complexity is the diversity, distinction and overlap between
communities: for example, not all Muslims are Arab, not all Palestinians are
Muslim, and not all Israelis are Jewish.
These insights help the Study attune to the diversity of experience, ensure that
recommendations are nuanced and move beyond a one-size-fits-all approach to
anti-racism. A key consideration in the next phase of the Study will be
understanding whether existing approaches to address racism in universities are
sufficiently nuanced to respond to the diversity of experiences.
(a)
First Nations experience
Increasing the number of First Nations students who complete university has
been identified as a priority for the National Education Accord. It aligns with the
Closing the Gap target to ensure First Nations students are supported to
participate and succeed in higher education. The Australian Government has
made significant commitments, including uncapped university places for First
Nations students and the Indigenous Student Success Program (ISSP) to fund
universities to support students.
However, Commission consultations highlighted the ongoing impact of racism on
First Nations students. Limited understanding of the historical and systematic
discrimination faced by First Nations students and ongoing experiences of racism
hamper efforts to increase participation. One academic at the Study’s initial First
Nations Academics Roundtable noted, ‘Racism is embedded in every space. You
can’t go into a university and not breathe it’. 34
Research shows that First Nations students have lower completion rates than
their non-Indigenous counterparts, with a nine-year completion rate of 47%,
compared to a 74% nine-year completion rate for non-Indigenous students. 35 The
impact of racism is well established in the research and cannot be
underestimated as a contributing factor to completion rates. Researchers
describe racism for First Nations students as:
Multifaceted in nature and can include: verbal racism (name calling, jokes),
behavioural racism (ignored, avoided, stared at), institutional
discrimination (unfair treatment) and macro-level racism (denial of
Aboriginal views of history, dominance of White values). 36
34