8 | Treatment of people in detention
The Commission considers this to be a significant
gap that needs to be urgently addressed;
particularly as there has been a history of fires being
lit during disturbances and the centre has been
threatened by bushfire. The Commission considers
the provision of BA training to the ERT team to be a
necessity.
RECOMMENDATION 27:
The Department and Serco should
provide breathing apparatus training to
the centre’s Emergency Response Team.
8.2 Relationships with staff
Most people interviewed told the Commission that,
generally, they had not encountered any problems
with Serco staff or other staff within the centre. One
person interviewed said that staff at YHIDC were far
better than at other centres. However, there were
a few people who felt they had been harassed or
intimidated by staff. They told the Commission that
they were afraid of speaking out about it because
they are allegedly threatened with having points
deducted from them (points can be used to make
purchases within the centre). Some people also
disclosed that, if they reported incidents between
themselves and staff, they felt nothing ever came
of it.
52
When asked about staff training needs to support
the detained population, Serco management
advised that there had been recent changes
to address an identified need for more mental
health training. Despite this, one detained person
interviewed explicitly stated that Serco staff needed
‘more mental health awareness.’ In one of the
written submissions received, the Commission was
additionally told that
[clients] … repeatedly voiced concerns that
Serco Officers do not understand their trauma
and experiences and that this contributes to
their sense of distress. A number of clients
have reported that they have been required
to repeatedly explain their trauma to Serco
Officers, and explain why they cannot
participate in certain activities that trigger
a trauma response.
The Commonwealth Ombudsman has also
previously observed that the centre’s
… detention service officers do not have
the training or skills to provide a mental
health response to detainees exhibiting
mental health vulnerabilities or in crisis. The
consequence of limited IHMS availability,
particularly after hours, results in a securityfocused response rather than the required
mental health response to detainees
presenting with mental health vulnerabilities.92
Given the significant rate of severe, complex,
comorbid mental health and substance use issues
(see mental health section), it is essential to provide
centre staff with adequate and ongoing training in
this area.