7.3 Accessing health
care services
People in detention can request medical assistance
through filling in a medical request form. Forms
are collected daily and triaged for appointments.
Based on what is written on the form, there is an
initial paper-based triage, then a face-to-face triage
with a nurse. The targeted response time for this
is 72 hours, however, urgent cases can be seen on
the day or within 24 hours. IHMS staff told us they
received up to 9 medical request forms per day.
All forms seen at various locations during the
inspection were in English only. It is unclear what
support is offered to people who are unable to
communicate their needs in English or who have
poor written English skills. Neither was it apparent
how accurately most people in detention were able
to describe their medical issues to generate an
appropriate triage response.
IHMS staff informed the Commission that, in
addition to the medical request forms, they were
also very responsive to concerns raised by security
or welfare staff about people who appeared unwell
but had not completed a form.
Nevertheless, we were advised by IHMS that there
was a 50% non‑attendance rate for face-to-face
triage appointments. This suggests that the current
model is not efficient or effective.
Additionally, people in immigration detention
cannot access mental health services and torture
and trauma counselling without being triaged by a
non‑mental health clinician, meaning that they have
to tell their story at least twice. One of the written
submissions received by the Commission stated
that accessing torture and trauma counselling was
particularly ‘problematic for clients who do not wish
to engage with IHMS.’
One person interviewed told the Commission
that he had a long history of severe depression
and needed to see a psychiatrist but had to see
the nurse and then the general practitioner first.
As they did not make the onward referral to the
psychiatrist, he was unable to access any mental
health care. Another person reported that they had
not been able to access psychology. He reported
that he had a history of depression and had made
a serious suicide attempt in the past. He said that
he wanted talking treatment but instead the general
practitioner offered an increase in medication,
which he did not want.
Requiring people in detention to see a general
nurse and then a general practitioner before they
can access a specialist mental health or torture and
trauma service does not meet the standard offered
by public community mental health services. It
also requires a detained person to tell their story
multiple times to access care, which is not best
practice from a therapeutic perspective.
RECOMMENDATION 13:
The Department and IHMS should
review the efficiency of the current
health services referral and triage
procedures within immigration
detention. This review should include
examining the accessibility of the
procedures and whether the mental
health and torture and trauma referral
system aligns with community mental
health service standards and best
practice.
Yongah Hill Immigration Detention Centre Inspection Report • 2024 • 37