ADOPTION LAWS: CHALLENGES CONCERNING PROCEDURE FROM HUMAN RIGHTS PERSPECTIVE
Myriad of provisions Governing Adoption and Guardianship: The diverse provisions of
adoption and guardianship provided by the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890; Hindu Adoption
and Maintenance Act, 1956; Juvenile Justice Act, 2015; Hindu Minority and Guardianship
Act and the personal laws of Muslims, Christians and Parsis and the customary practices
recognised by the Courts has created a never ending web of hassles. What is disheartening
is that their grey matter is often used to transgress the rights of children, especially in case of
inter-country adoptions. If we compare them, one can easily find that though children welfare
is given priority, but not much has been achieved on part of gender justice and religion parity.
To achieve a safe haven for children, it is a must that a comprehensive legislation governing
every single aspect shall be framed so that the anomalies prevalent in the above-mentioned
legislations can be done away with. No doubt, the Adoption Regulations, 2017, were framed
to achieve that clarity, but it has created hassles for in-country adoptions by providing a free
ticket to either opt for it or not. Even in the Ashwini Kumar Upadhyaya v. Union of India,53 it has
been pleaded that multifarious personal laws are causing delay and confusion during judicial
adjudication of cases. Therefore, to control fissiparous tendencies, and to promote fraternity
unity and integrity, which is the aim and objective of the Constitution of India, uniform
guidelines of “Adoption and Guardianship” in the spirit of Articles 14, 15, 21 and 44 of the
Constitution and international conventions must be framed.”54
Conclusion and Suggestions
The institution of adoption was started to serve the social institution of son-ship among the
Hindus. It was considered essential for a Hindu for religious purposes to have a son. There
seems to be two reasons for having sons: For carrying the name of the family ahead, as the
Hindu family is a male dominated family for the purpose of property. It was also considered
essential that the last rites after the death of an individual must be performed by the son.
The practice based upon religion was so strong that it was transferred to the other religious
communities in India as well. Other religious communities accepted the institution in a very
restricted way. The Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, helped a bit in this regard to familiarise
adoption in other religious communities. The Act, 1890, has made an attempt to regularise
53
54
Writ Petition (C) No. 1000/2000,
PIL under Article 32 of the Constitution available at: https://www.livelaw.in/pdf_upload/pdf_upload-380682.pdf (Visited on October 20,
2022).
87