When speaking to potential employers via phone,
all was very promising. Until we meet in person
and I sense them withdrawing and hesitation
because of my appearance - tall, brown, built, and
dominant. (S206)
A female healthcare worker told us about being
stereotyped in the workplace and feeling as though
they could not win no matter what their personality
was like. They felt they constantly needed to prove
themselves to their employer:
The industry considers Pacific Islanders as too loud
if they ask questions about work conditions and
other issues. On the other hand being too quiet
and reserved is seen as lacking in confidence, or
not competent in the work assignment/workplace.
It’s almost like they (employer) expect you to prove
to them (employer) you are capable of what they
have employed you to do. They don’t say that you
have a quiet personality and is capable of doing the
work. (S187)
Available data supports these experiences
The context for these stories is that Pacific peoples
have the highest reported experience of workplace
discrimination, with 11.7 percent of New Zealandborn Pacific peoples reporting they have experienced
workplace discrimination and 9.6 percent of Pacificborn Pacific peoples reporting the same.48
More recent research indicates there was a growth in
the number of Pacific peoples reporting experiences
of discrimination between 2008-2014.49 Research
also shows that Pacific peoples are unlikely to report
facing discrimination at work as they fear reprisal or
victimisation. This suggests that internal methods of
reporting discrimination may result in under-reporting
given national levels of experiences in discrimination.50
72
Our analysis of the available statistics suggests that
the unexplained portion of the pay gap between
Pacific and Pākehā men is around 73 percent, while
that between Pacific and Pākehā women is around
61 percent. After controlling for occupation, industry
education, this proportion is likely to be largely
accounted for by discrimination and unconscious
bias, although it can also be accounted for by issues
not measured by available data sets. International
research into the gender pay gap shows a similar
unaccounted portion due to discrimination.51
In our focus industries of construction, manufacturing
and healthcare, we note that research shows racism
can manifest in specific ways. In manufacturing, much
of it is tied to communication, while racism contributes
to precarious employment conditions and poor health
and safety practices in construction. In healthcare,
racism is linked to lower-paid work and lack of
recognition of Pacific region qualifications and work
experience.52
Many participants felt their experiences of
discrimination were likely to inform the Pacific Pay
Gap. One person articulated this during a group
talanoa, identifying that these experiences could
involve both ethnicity and gender:
I think what we will find and this is probably what
you already know, is that there is discrimination.
And one of the reasons there is a pay gap is that
there’s discrimination against who you are as a Pacific
Islander, there’s discrimination against women in the
workforce. (T019)
We note, however, that while some of the participants
who identified as female may also have experienced
discrimination on the basis of their gender, most of
the stories foregrounded a person’s Pacific identity as
the basis for the discrimination they experienced.
48
Daldy, Bridget, Jacques Poot, and Matthew Roskruge. “Perception of Workplace Discrimination among Immigrants and
Native Born New Zealanders.” Australian Journal of Labour Economics 16, no. 1 (2013): 137-154. https://search.informit.org/
doi/10.3316/informit.363066000980903.
49
Yeung, Stanley, and Charles Crothers. “Patterns of Perceived Discrimination in New Zealand and Their Social Contexts.” New
Zealand Sociology 31, no. 7 (2016): 205-226. https://search.informit.org/doi/10.3316/informit.561391235263905.
50
New Zealand Human Rights Commission, Talanoa; Davis, Alyssa, and Elise Gould. Closing the Pay Gap and Beyond: A
Comprehensive Strategy for Improving Economic Security for Women and Families. Washington DC: Economic Policy Institute,
2015. https://www.epi.org/publication/closing-the-pay-gap-and-beyond/.
51
Davis and Gould, Closing the Pay Gap and Beyond, 202.
52
Matada Research Group and Human Rights Commission, Pacific Pay Gap Inquiry: Literature Review.