Many Pacific workers shared that they were not
receiving the opportunity to negotiate pay or were
being declined for pay negotiations despite holding
qualifications. Within the health sector in particular, a
significant number of Pacific workers told us they had
the relevant qualifications and started new roles only
to discover further down the line that they started on
lower pay than their fellow colleagues. One Pacific
health worker told us that “I discovered my new
colleagues were of equal qualifications to me but
were paid more” (S177).
When people became aware of differences like
these, they felt they were often ignored when they
tried to make the case for equitable treatment. One
Pacific healthcare worker told us that “there is always
an excuse to say why my salary is not in the level
where it supposed to be, although I have a good
qualification, years of service and experience, same
as others” (S178).
Lack of pay transparency by employers
Another feature of the recruitment process that
discouraged and deterred Pacific workers was the
lack of transparency from employers regarding
salary bands and qualifications. Pacific peoples
found it challenging that hiring parties “aren’t
forthcoming with what their annual salary range is,
they don’t provide this info” (S091). This was seen
as a barrier as it prevented Pacific job seekers from
determining salary expectations. One Pacific health
worker told us:
I will email to enquire about the potential
salary range. They’ll ask me, what’s my salary
expectation – almost to catch me out? It’s hard
to find typically what a role is worth – often there
may be a few websites that have the lower,
median, upper range salary for NZ companies.
(S091)
Opportunities for Pacific peoples to support one
another
For many Pacific workers, securing employment
often happened through personal networks. These
networks include family and community members
and provide an alternative avenue to gaining
employment that is positive for Pacific job seekers.
One Pacific corporate worker told us that “most jobs
are through friends I know who refer me” (S324).
The collective nature of Pacific culture is pivotal
in the recruitment process. In the cases of Pacific
peoples who shared their success stories in finding
work, there was a sense of relief and the recruitment
process was viewed as a positive experience when
they knew someone. As one Pacific worker said, it
is “easy and good when there’s someone you know
there” (S647).
Utilising the Pacific community can be an effective
alternative method to find work rather than seeking
support from recruitment agencies or the traditional
mode of applying for a job. While this is often a
positive experience for these Pacific workers, the
literature on networks and jobs tends to suggest
that using personal networks can contribute to
occupational segregation if the people in your
personal network only work in certain sectors and
certain jobs. These will then be the same kinds of
jobs open to the people looking for work.40
A group of Pacific workers from the education
sector shared the following sentiments on how
personal networks can unintentionally contribute to
occupational segregation:
Another Pacific healthcare worker who is looking to
progress in her career told us it “has been challenging
job searching particularly when pay information is
not available on sites to determine whether or not I
should be applying” (S160).
40
Most of them because they are migrants, they
go into that horticulture work … You know, their
children are finishing and going straight into that.
So we have this dream, this aspiration as Pasifika
that we are going to come to New Zealand, the
land of milk and honey, but if our experience, if
we started off the back foot, anyway our kids are
going to follow. Because like [name] said, people
don’t know what they don’t know. (T004)
Matada Research Group, Pacific Pay Gap Inquiry Literature Review.
Voices of Pacific peoples
43