What we know about racial discrimination in the
workplace
As discrimination is a factor in the Pacific Pay Gap
– in both its explained and unexplained portions
– we briefly outline here what we know about
the discrimination Pacific peoples’ experience in
employment. This includes:
• research we commissioned on the prevalence of
bullying and harassment
• our own data relating to discrimination in
employment
• data from MBIE
• data from the General Social Survey run by Stats
NZ
• data from Diversity Works’ Workplace Diversity
survey
• findings from the engagement the Commission
undertook to inform the development of a
National Action Plan Against Racism.
Research into bullying and harassment
In June 2022, we commissioned Kantar Public
to undertake a national survey of 2,512 workers
in Aotearoa New Zealand to understand the
prevalence of the experience of sexual harassment,
racial harassment and bullying in the workplace.36
The survey asked people to respond to a range of
listed behaviours under each of these headings.
When disaggregated by ethnicity, the survey
showed that Pacific workers fared the worst for
all of these forms of workplace mistreatment. For
example, 35 percent of Pacific men and 43 percent
of Pacific women identified having experienced at
least one type of behaviour associated with sexual
harassment in the last five years. This compares to
the rate of 30 percent experienced by the workforce
overall.
36
36
For racial harassment, 62 percent of Pacific peoples
reported experiencing at least one of the 12 racial
harassment behaviours measured in the survey.
Asian workers also reported the same rate of racial
harassment, followed by Māori at 52 percent. Pacific
workers were the most likely ethnicity to report
experiencing multiple racial harassment behaviours.
Over a third of Pacific workers (37 percent) were
found to have experienced four or more of the types
of racial harassment the survey captured over the
last five years.
Pacific peoples were the ethnic group most likely to
report that they had often or always experienced
at least one workplace bullying behaviour listed in
the survey. For Pacific workers, 26 percent reported
this prevalence of bullying, while for Māori, it is
22 percent, NZ European 20 percent and Asian 18
percent.
Given that Pacific workers disproportionately
experience these forms of workplace violence,
they are therefore likely to disproportionately
suffer the impacts. For example, the same study
found that workers who experienced bullying or
harassment reported that they found it harder to
do their job (29 percent), resigned from their job
(21 percent), left the industry (10 percent), had their
job or career prospects affected (9 percent) and
found it difficult to get another job (5 percent). In
addition, many of these impacts continued to affect
workers in an ongoing way (63 percent), resulting
in longer-term impacts. Very few accessed external
complaints mechanisms, with 1 percent reporting
that they contacted the New Zealand Human Rights
Commission, the Employment Relations Authority
or MBIE respectively. This evidence suggests that
New Zealand Human Rights Commission. Experiences of Workplace Bullying and Harassment in Aotearoa New Zealand.
Wellington: New Zealand Human Rights Commission, 2022. https://www.hrc.co.nz/files/3816/6233/0960/New_Zealand_
Human_Rights_Commission_-_Experiences_of_Workplace_Bullying_and_Harassment_in_Aotearoa_New_Zealandcompressed.pdf.