What the data does show is that there is a wide and
persistent pay gap between Pacific workers and
other workers. In 2021, the gap between the median
hourly earnings of Pacific men and Pākehā4 men
was 18.8 percent. The gap was even larger for Pacific
women compared with Pākehā men at 25.1 percent.
Alongside Māori women, Pacific men and women
experience the largest pay gaps compared to other
ethnic groups. There is no sign that this gap is closing.
To better understand the causes of pay inequities
and to seek ways to identify and eliminate them,
the Human Rights Commission set up the Inquiry.
The Inquiry was conducted under section 5(2)(h) of
the Human Rights Act 1993, which provides that the
Commission can:
The Inquiry was supported by an expert Reference
Group made up of representatives from the Council
of Trade Unions, Employers and Manufacturers
Association, Ministry for Pacific Peoples, Ministry of
Business, Innovation and Employment, two other
private sector voices convened by the Commission.
Centred on the experiences of Pacific workers, the
Inquiry set out to focus on three key industries where
Pacific workers are concentrated: manufacturing,
construction, and healthcare. However, there was
an overwhelming response from workers in a range
of other industries including education, finance, the
public service, retail, and social work. Our findings
therefore reflect the wide range of employment
experiences shared with us.
inquire generally into any matter, including
an enactment or law, or any practice, or any
procedure, whether governmental or nongovernmental, if it appears to the Commission
that the matter involves, or may involve, the
infringement of human rights.5
How was the Inquiry conducted?
The Inquiry was conducted between August 2021 and
July 2022 through a broad and diverse combination
of approaches, including:
· a dedicated website that hosted two surveys:
one for workers (738 responses) and one for
employers (16 responses)
· face-to-face and online interviews, talanoa (a
Pacific form of narrative inquiry) and workshops/
webinars with community groups, union groups
and other representative bodies
– a total of 470 oral contributions (including 425
Pacific workers, 24 employers, four unions and one
peak body)
· a literature review
· empirical analysis of income data
10
· research on the national prevalence of bullying,
racial and sexual harassment in the workplace
· engagements with the Equal Employment
Opportunities Commissioner.
While we planned to conduct our engagements faceto-face, most had to be conducted online due to the
resurgence of COVID-19 in August 2021, which led to
a national lockdown and three further periods of
lockdown for Auckland.
Wherever possible, online engagement occurred at
the convenience of the participant – whether from a
quiet space or a shopping mall with free WiFi (see the
appendices for further demographic information
about participants).
4
Pākeha will be used in this report to refer to those categorised as ‘European’ in StatsNZ data. This category includes those
who identify with a European ethnicity (eg New Zealand European, English, Dutch, etc.), with or without other ethnicities. We
have chosen to use the te reo term “Pākehā” due to its grounding here in Aotearoa New Zealand.
5
Human Rights Act 1993, s 5(2)(h).