Annual Report 2008-2009
4.138 The NHRC took cognizance of a complaint which alleged that a pair of surgical scissors
was left inside the abdomen of one Binapani Khatua of Radharampur village in Cuttack District
by the doctors of SCB Medical College and Hospital in Cuttack, Orissa during an operation.
When the patient complained of pain, her uterus was removed.
4.139 A report received from the Chief Medical Officer, Cuttack confirmed negligence on the
part of the accused doctors. Another report received from the Secretary, Department of Health
& Family Welfare, Government of Orissa revealed that departmental proceedings had been
initiated against the two accused doctors. The NHRC viewed the entire incident as a serious
case of professional negligence resulting in violation of human rights of the victim, who not
only suffered physical pain for years, but was also deprived of her motherhood. The NHRC
recommended to the State Government of Orissa to pay Rs. 5, 00,000 as monetary relief to the
victim, to follow-up the departmental proceedings against the accused doctors, and also submit
an action taken report.
4.140 The proof of payment of monetary relief to the victim has been received by the NHRC.
However, action taken report on the departmental proceedings is still awaited from the State
Government.
k)
Electrocution Case
32.
Death of Suresh Chander Engaged by Uttarakhand Power Corporation Limited
(Case No.921/35/2003-2004)
4.141 One Suresh Chander became a victim of electrocution on 28 May 2003. He had been
engaged by the maintenance staff of Uttarakhand Power Corporation to work on 440 watt lt.
line in an unauthorized manner. While making repairs of the transmission line he died of
electrocution.
4.142 On examination of the report of the Electrical Inspector, the NHRC found that at the
instance of the maintenance staff of the Corporation, Suresh Chander was found to be working
in an unlawful manner at the time of the accident. The Commission held that although his
name was not entered in the muster roll, he was entitled to claim compensation on the same
lines as a regular worker. With these observations, the Commission recommended to
Uttarakhand Power Corporation Limited to pay a sum of Rs. 2, 00,000 as monetary relief to the
next of kin of the victim. Disciplinary action against the maintenance staff was also recommended
by the Commission.
4.143 The compliance report, along with proof of payment, is awaited and the matter is under
consideration of the Commission.
l)
Other Cases
33.
Man Languishing in Jail for 34 years in Rajasthan
(Case No. 55/20/26/2008-2009 & Case No.2978/20/26/2007-2008)
51