Annual Report 2008-2009
from the scene, leaving the labourers at the mercy of the Bhatta owner, who in turn forces
the labourers to work without payment till he recovers the entire money paid as advance
to the labour contractor(s).
(e)
The maintenance of records in most of the Bhattas was found to be very poor. This is
because the brick kiln owners and contractors concealed the payments made to the
labourers to avoid any kind of inspections made by the authorities.
(f)
At various places, the Vigilance Committees u/s 13 of the Bonded Labour System (Abolition)
Act, 1976 had not been constituted, and if constituted, hardly carried out their mandate as
envisaged u/s 14 of the Act.
4.116 The above observations were placed before the Commission, whereby it directed the
District Magistrates of Aligarh, Bulandshahr and Badaun districts of Uttar Pradesh for their
rehabilitation. It also directed the District Magistrate of Jhajjar district of Haryana to initiate
legal action against the brick kiln owners.
4.117 The response of the District Magistrates is awaited and the matter continues to be under
consideration of the Commission.
j)
Right to Health
26.
Death due to Negligence of Medical Officers in Rajasthan
(Case No. 1618/20/2000-2001)
4.118 One Rakesh Sharma complained to the NHRC about the alleged negligence of Medical
Officers of Mahavir Bhim Singh Government Hospital in Rajasthan which resulted in the death
of four patients.
4.119 A report received from the Assistant Secretary, Government of Rajasthan revealed that
one of the victims named Suresh Mathur was referred to another hospital in Jaipur on the
request of his family members. There was nothing on record regarding the death of the second
victim, named Om Prakash. The cause of death about the third victim named Baby Sunita was
enquired into by the Lok Auykta and the matter was dropped as the allegations could not be
proved. As far as the case of Abdul Majid, the fourth victim was concerned, the Government of
Rajasthan decided to initiate departmental proceedings against the neuro surgeon, Dr. Krishna
Hari Sharma.
4.120 The Commission recommended Rs. 1, 00,000 as monetary relief to be paid to the next of
kin of the deceased, Abdul Majid. The case was closed by the NHRC on receipt of the compliance
report.
27.
Death of an Adivasi Woman in Betul District of Madhya Pradesh due to Want of Proper Medical
Care in Hospital (Case No.743/12/2001-2002)
47