30
...
...
...
...
..
S I T UAT I O N I N G U JA R AT
3.8 Throughout the period under review, the Commission continued to receive
detailed reports from its Special Rapporteur in Gujarat, who monitored with
great dedication the degree of compliance - or rather of non-compliance - of
the Commission's recommendations by the Government of Gujarat, relating the
realities on the ground to the relevant Proceedings of the Commission and the
responses and reports of the State Government. In the course of performing
his duties, Shri Nampoothiri extensively toured the districts of Kheda, Anand,
Panchmahals, Vadodara and Sabarkantha, visiting some two dozen villages, in
addition to several areas of Ahmedabad which had been severely affected by
the violence that had occurred. In the process, he visited 22 relief camps which
were providing temporary accommodation to those affected by the riots (these
camps were officially closed on 30 June 2002, though a number of displaced
persons are yet to be provided with permanent or adequate solutions to their
problems). Shri Nampoothiri also held discussions as and when needed with
representatives of non-governmental organizations providing succour and relief
to the affected persons and intervened, on numerous occasions, with the
competent public servants whose duty it was to maintain law and order,
investigate and prosecute those responsible for the carnage and the violation
of human rights and who, additionally, were responsible for the over-all
conditions in the camps and the provision of appropriate compensation to the
victims of the violence or to their next-of-kin.
3.9 As various aspects of the situation continued to disturb the Commission
greatly, its then Chairperson, Justice Shri J.S. Verma, shortly before he
relinquished office, considered it his duty to address a letter to the Prime
Minister of India on 3 January 2003, setting out these concerns. The full text
of that letter may be seen at Annexure 1.
3.10 In that letter, Justice Verma, after referring to the recommendations
contained in the Commission's Proceedings of 1 April and 31 May 2002, went
on to observe:
"……. with great respect, that if our country should fall short in
rendering justice, promptly and effectively, to the victims, their
families, dependants and other persons or groups connected with
the victims, a serious travesty of the law will occur with potentially
grave consequences, not only to those immediately affected, but to
the reputation of our country and its institutions of governance,
including the judiciary and the National Human Rights Commission."
N AT I O N A L H U M A N R I G H T S C O M M I S S I O N