Children with disability and youth justice
(f)
353. Children with disability are overrepresented in the juvenile justice system,
particularly children with intellectual disabilities or mental health issues. In
NSW, 83.3% of children in the juvenile justice system met the criteria for at
least one psychological disorder—six times the prevalence rate children in
the general population.352 Disability advocacy organisations have argued
that the high incarceration rate is due to the failures in mental health, child
protection, housing, disability and community service systems to provide
appropriate assessment and supports for children with disability. 353
354. The Commission is concerned that in some jurisdictions declarations of
unfitness to stand trial may lead to the indefinite detention of
unconvicted people with disability, including children with disability. 354
Under Western Australia’s Criminal Law (Mentally Impaired Accused) Act 1996
a person can be indefinitely detained without trial if found unfit to stand
trial.355 A person can spend a longer time in detention than if they pleaded
guilty and were sentenced to imprisonment for the offence. There are no
special procedures for children.356
355. In a submission to the Senate Community Affairs Committee in 2016, the
Commission raised concerns with laws that can impose detention on
people found to be unfit to stand trial. It recommended that there be
effective limits on the period of detention that can be imposed, and
requirements for periodic review of the need for detention.357
356. Children with FASD are at particular risk of being held in indefinite
detention and are overrepresented in the juvenile justice system.358 A
recent Australian study of FASD in Australia’s juvenile detention population
reports that:
There is increasing concern regarding the forensic implications of FASD in
Australia, as the neuropsychological sequelae can affect all aspects of the
legal proceedings, including the person understanding the expectations
and providing credible evidence in forensic interviews, fitness to plead,
capacity to stand trial and the process of sentencing. 359
Recommendation 53: Australian Governments ensure that laws that allow
for children to be detained following a finding of unfitness to stand trial, or
a verdict of not guilty by reason of mental impairment:
•
impose effective limits on the total period of detention
•
require regular reviews of the need for detention
63