(c)
Detention as a measure of last resort
336. While the numbers of children in juvenile detention have decreased in
recent years, on an average day in 2016–2017, 913 (17%) of all the children
in contact with the juvenile justice system were in detention.322 More than
half of those children were unsentenced, awaiting the outcome of their
legal matter or sentencing. Just over half of all children in detention were
Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islanders.323
(i)
Diversion
337. The availability of appropriate diversionary programs is an essential part
of reducing the numbers of children in juvenile justice and juvenile
detention. Given the level of contact of Aboriginal and Torres Strait
Islander peoples with criminal justice processes, and the integral role that
juvenile offending plays in this, diversionary processes are particularly
important for ensuring lasting reductions in the rates of Aboriginal and
Torres Strait Islander overrepresentation in detention.324
338. While diversion is a key principle of the juvenile justice systems in all
jurisdictions in Australia, it is underutilised for a variety of reasons,
including limits to who can access the programs, insufficient staffing
allocated to diversion, and lack of sufficient appropriately funded and
culturally appropriate programs.325 The NT Royal Commission showed that
in 2015–2016, only 35% of children apprehended in the Northern Territory
were diverted. This is despite evidence that diversion has been successful
in reducing recidivism.326 Nationwide, research also shows, Aboriginal
children are less likely to be diverted than non-Indigenous children.327
(ii)
Bail laws
339. Onerous bail laws play a role in the disproportionately high, and
increasing, numbers of children on remand in juvenile detention. For
example, the Law Council of Victoria submitted that, in Victoria, the
number of children on remand has increased from 538 in 2007–2008 to
1,069 in 2016–2017. In 2017, the number of children detained on remand
accounted for 80% of all detained children in the Parkville Juvenile Justice
Centre.328 The Law Council of Victoria argues that recent amendments to
the bail laws, which expand the categories of offences with no
presumption in favour of bail and create a more onerous threshold for
bail, have contributed to increasing numbers of children on remand.329
340. The NT Royal Commission reported that, in the Northern Territory on an
average day in 2015–2016, 71% of children in detention were on
59