133
amendment requires land to be
offered back at market value or
less. The Act remains in force but
has been ‘under review’ since the
early 1990s (Waitangi Tribunal,
2010:743 (Wai 863)).
1985: The Waitangi Tribunal remit
is extended to hear claims going
back to 1840; the Crown controls
the whole process. The increase
in claims following this change
was huge and so was the Pākehā
backlash which included concern
at the amount of resources going
into settlement and reconciliation
processes (Spoonley, 1993; Came,
2012). The Tribunal’s findings are
still not binding on the Crown and
remains that way (For example,
in passing the Foreshore Seabed
Act 2004, the Labour-led Coalition
government acted against the
advice of the Tribunal) (Waitangi
Tribunal, 2004 cited in Came, 2012).
In 1986 Ngāi Tahu lodges their
claim with the Waitangi Tribunal.
This claim was initiated in 1849.
It is the first large claim that the
tribunal heard under its power
to investigate grievances dating
back to 1840. (Ngāi Tahu Claims
Settlement Act 1998). By the time of
the 1991 Waitangi Tribunal findings
on the Ngāi Tahu claim, at least
a dozen different commissions,
inquiries, courts and tribunals had
repeatedly established the veracity
and justice of the Ngāi Tahu claim.
(Te Rūnanga o Ngāi Tahu - The
Settlement –https://ngaitahu.iwi.
nz/ngai-tahu/the-settlement/
claim-history/)
Education
In the 1980s Māori tamariki start
to be measured against a deficit
model to understand Māori
Human Rights Commission
educational performance. This
discourse continues through to
the early 2000s under a number
of guises including the phrase
‘Māori underachievement’. This
more broadly fuels the belief that
problems lay – and were inherent
to – Māori students themselves
rather than to the education
system.
Te Reo Māori
Te Reo Māori is still forbidden in
many public places such as the
Courts. (Waitangi Tribunal, 1986)
1982: Māori parents start the
first Kōhanga Reo at Waiwhetū,
Lower Hutt.
1984: The scaling system of the
School Certificate Examination
Board controlled the number of
students who pass. It operated so
that 80 out of every 100 candidates
sitting a foreign language were
allowed to pass but only 38 out of
every 100 candidates sitting the
Māori language, were allowed to
pass (Waitangi Tribunal, 1986).
1985: around the country there
are 416 Kōhanga Reo with 6000
tamariki. The fee charged is $25
per week per child. However,
Māori parents note that the English
language education system means
their children lose their fluency
in te reo Māori after six months
at primary school (Waitangi
Tribunal, 1986)
1985: the te reo Māori claim
is heard.
1986: Waitangi Tribunal findings
say Māori children are not being
adequately educated and alludes
to institutional racism
“We think that the system is at fault
and has been at fault for many
years. We suspect that somewhere
at some influential level in the
Department, there remains an
attitude—it may be in planning or
in education boards, or at the level
of principals or head teachers …a
vestige of the attitude expressed by
a former Director of Education who
wrote in the middle of the first half
of this century:
“.. The natural abandonment of the
native tongue involves no loss on
the Māori.” (Waitangi Tribunal, Te
Reo Māori Claim 1986, Wai 11).
Politics
After extending the Tribunal’s remit
back to 1840, there are deliberate
attempts to redefine the terms
of Te Tiriti.
1987: Rather than implement
the Māori text of Te Tiriti, the
Court of Appeal proposes ‘Treaty
principles’ to form the basis of
Crown-Māori engagement
(Kelsey 1991 in Came, 2012).
1989: the Labour Government
invents separate Treaty
principles ie:
• government (Kāwanatanga
principle)
• self-management
(rangatiratanga principle)
• equality
• reasonable co-operation
• redress.
Government departments interpret
the Treaty principles for their
own purposes, and this carries on
until the end of the 20th century.
(In 2010, the Special Rapporteur
observed that the Treaty’s
principles appear to be vulnerable
to political discretion, resulting
in their perpetual insecurity
and instability (Anaya, 2010 in
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات