76
Maranga Mai!
I am good at maths, but my teacher just thinks I
am stupid so never gave me any time except to
get me in trouble. But if you are Pākehā it’s all
good (Office of the Children’s Commissioner and
New Zealand School Trustees Association,
2018, pp. 19–20).
It is just pretty much like you must belong to a
specific culture to receive fair treatment. If you
are a Māori or Islander, then you are pretty much
just treated like shit ( The Southern Initiative et al,
2020b, p. 39).
Testimony from non-Māori students support
these observations:
Like before the teacher knew how intelligent my
Māori friends were, they considered them dumb
Māori. But as soon as they showed that they were
bright, it was like, oh, you’re not really Māori cause
your mother is Pākehā. So it’s like as long as you
showed the stereotype of what a Māori was, it
was like you’re a Māori, and if you weren’t, it was
like, ‘Oh, well you’re not really Māori’ (Prasad,
2000, p. 95).
The way teachers treat Māori reveals how many have
lower expectations for them:
Tama felt he was treated ‘dumber’ than Pākehā
children, and commented feeling that, ‘Māori
were only expected to achieve so much, and never
anything more on top of it’ (Prasad, 2000, p. 95).
Evidence from students also speaks to direct
interpersonal racism from teachers:
Being Māori. Some teachers are racist.
They say bad things about us (Berryman and
Eley, 2018, p. 108).
Teachers shame us. They say we’re thick, we
smell. Our uniforms are paru (dirty). They shame
us in class. Put us down. Don’t even try to say our
names properly. Say things about our whānau
(Berryman and Eley, 2018, p. 108).
More recently, Chevron described a teacher
at their school known for being openly racist,
who ‘made a late list specifically for Māori
students and called students racist slurs like
cannibal, savages, coconuts, pirates or terrorists’
(Muru-Lanning, 2020).
“Our principal said straight-up I don’t like brown
people” (Ngati Frybread in Muru-Lanning, 2020).
The evidence of Jamie demonstrates that racist
teachers often seek to disguise their comments:
You get teachers every now and then, you know,
passing remarks about Māori students, but they
say it in a way that you’d think they were joking
like ‘Oh, you’re just a no-hoper’, or ‘Oh, you’re
just going to end up at the freezing works or
something’. And so, you know, all the other kids
would laugh. Only one person ever mentioned
the word ‘Māori.’ Other than that, comments,
you know, were directed at a Māori student,
but they never said ‘Māori’ so it wasn’t obvious
(Prasad, 2000, p. 95).
Tauira Māori push back
There are examples of students pushing back:
The teacher was telling the class about the story
of the Māori, and somewhat eloquently the
teacher was explaining the barbaric habits of an
old Māori chief. The teacher informed the class
he was a murderer and cannibal. Breaking the
spell, a small child rose indignantly to protest ‘He
did nothing of the sort, I know, cause he was my
great-grandfather’ (The Press, 1933).
Internalised racism
Racist shaming of tauira Māori in education causes
shame, embarrassment and poor outcomes for
Māori. Each event constitutes a micro-aggression
often resulting in internalised racism whereby Māori
students internalise feelings of alienation, failure and
inferiority. As one student described it: It’s not good to
be Māori. “I didn’t learn anything positive at school
about my own culture” (Muru-Lanning, 2020).
And another:
They made me feel like I was different, and
they were better. On the first day at intermediate,
a teacher said I looked bad so I decided I would
live up to that (The Southern Initiative, Ministry
of Education & The Auckland Co-Design Lab,
2020a, p. 24).