impact on policy-making and legislative
processes has been more extensive and
arguably more important than its impact
in the courts. Its main effects have been
on the legislature and executive, fostering
a lively, if sometimes fragile, human rights
culture within government. While it has
not attracted extensive public attention,
and its workings have not always been
apparent to the broader community, the
[ACT Human Rights Act] has operated in
subtle ways to enhance the standing of
human rights in the ACT.6
Similar effects have been noted in relation
to the Victorian Charter. The Victorian Equal
Opportunity and Human Rights Commission
reported the following examples of upstream
impacts:
Shaped major legislative reforms to
provide stronger and fairer laws. For
example the Mental Health Act 2014.
Consultation over six years in developing
this Act enabled the Victorian Government,
service providers and community to
consider the significant human rights
issues raised by mental health treatment,
using the Charter as a framework. The
new Act took a significant step forward
in protecting the rights of people with
psycho-social disabilities.
Improved decision-making in Victorian
public bodies. It has done this by ensuring
that public decision makers must consider
and act compatibly with human rights.
This has transformed day-to-day decision
making. For example, the Department of
Health and Human Services’ public housing
policy and procedure manuals include
information about Charter obligations and
guide decision makers to consider rights in
the delivery of housing services.
Laid the foundations for the development
of a culture of human rights within
public authorities. Human rights have
become part of the everyday business
of government, incorporated into key
policies, guidelines and initiatives. For
example, in 2018 the Port Phillip City
Council used the Charter framework to
tackle rough sleeping in the city.7
While the implementation of the Queensland
Human Rights Act is still in its early stages,
Free & Equal consultees noted that it is already
having preventative impacts, including in
relation to preventing unfair exclusions in the
education context; and ensuring human rightscompliant treatment in relation to compulsory
mental health interventions.
Early consideration of rights impacts also
results in less downstream litigation and
associated costs. As submitted by Queensland
Advocacy Incorporated, ‘the costs [of
implementing a Human Rights Act] would not
be disproportionately high and would be offset
by significant economic benefits that would
increase over time’.8
The positive duty should ultimately result in a
transformative cultural shift within government.
It should make rights protection a core part of
government business, not just an afterthought,
and beyond preparing statements of
compatibility for Bills or legislative instruments.
The British Institute of Human Rights recently
explained the role of the UK positive duty in
instituting a human rights culture across the
public service:
A human rights culture is one that fosters
basic respect for human rights and creates
a climate in which such respect becomes
an integral part of our way of life and a
reference point for our dealing with public
authorities.
140
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات