There should also be permanent, dedicated
internal departmental teams with human rights
expertise and responsibility for consultation
and education on Human Rights Act matters;
the development and implementation of human
rights action plans by federal departments
and agencies; the development of tailored
guidelines, checklists and resources to enable
staff within public authorities to make human
rights-compliant decisions within their areas
of competence; and respect for human rights
included within public sector codes of conduct.
The Commission considers that it would have
a central role in providing tailored and general
education about the Human Rights Act for
public authorities, and would require dedicated
ongoing resourcing to do so.
(e) Procedural duties
• Participation duty
In addition to the positive duty on public
authorities to consider and act in accordance
with human rights, the Commission proposes
that an overarching ‘participation duty’ be
introduced into a Human Rights Act. The
participation duty would primarily operate as
an aspect of the binding positive duty on public
authorities.
The participation duty would also apply to
proponents of legislation in a non-binding
respect, reflected in Statements of Compatibility
and assessed by the Parliamentary Joint
Committee on Human Rights (PJCHR).
Participation duty on public authorities
The participation duty would require public
authorities to ensure the participation of certain
groups and individuals in relation to policies
and decisions that directly or disproportionately
affect their rights. The ‘participation duty’
addresses a fundamental problem in the
development of federal policies and decisions –
inadequate engagement with the very people to
whom those decisions directly apply.
The Commission’s proposal for a participation
duty draws on international human rights law
standards and common law procedural fairness
principles. It would synthesise procedures
concerning consultations and set clear
standards, fleshing out what participation means
in relation to certain groups that are often
overlooked in decision-making processes.
International law requires specific participation
measures to be undertaken regarding decisions
affecting the rights of First Nations peoples,
children and persons with disability. The
participation duty would be a means of realising
key procedural elements of the existing rights in
the Human Rights Act, in relation to these three
groups.
The duty will apply differently to each of these
groups, as defined by the relevant international
instruments. However, the same underlying
requirement applies — when decisions will
affect the rights of members of these groups,
public authorities have a duty to ensure their
participation in those decisions.
• Where decisions of public authorities will
affect the rights of First Nations peoples
and communities, participation processes
should be facilitated in line with UNDRIP
principles and standards relevant to
consultation and participation.
• When individual children are affected by
a decision, the ‘best interests’ principle
should be applied, and the child should be
heard, with their views given due weight
in accordance with their age and maturity.
When children as a group are affected
by proposed policies or laws, the best
interests of children should be proactively
considered, and children should be
consulted as part of the development
process.
FREE AND EQUAL A Human Rights Act for Australia 2022
21