Free & Equal consultees suggested ways
to encourage ‘opting-in’ and voluntary
acceptance of human rights obligations
within the businesses sector. For example, the
Federal Government could give preference
to entities that voluntarily comply with the
Human Rights Act in Government tenders and
contracting processes. Where entities receive
federal funding, there could be contractual
requirements to comply with the Human Rights
Act attached to that funding; or preference
given to entities that already accept Human
Rights Act obligations. In this regard, the
Victorian Charter review recommended having
a whole-of-government policy to include Charter
obligations in relevant State contracts and
adding a provision to the Charter to encourage
this inclusion.49 It was noted that this would help
provide certainty as to which entities are public
authorities and would encourage commitment
and consistent application of the Human Rights
Act. The Commission proposes adopting this
approach for a federal Human Rights Act.
The Australian Lawyers Alliance submitted that
regulatory bodies should include requirements
for human rights compliance as a precondition
for licensing or industry accreditation, including
requirements for annual reporting of human
rights compliance by organisations in order to
maintain their licensing or accreditation status.50
This could encompass bodies including the
Aged Care Quality and Safety Commission, the
National Disability Insurance Agency and the
Australian Prudential Regulation Authority. The
Commission endorses this approach.
(c) Use of regulations
resolve uncertainty about whether entities
at the margins are functional public
authorities. In this way, the Government
can make a clear statement that an entity
is bound by public authority obligations,
when there is a need to resolve doubt.52
The Commission favours a similar approach in
the federal context.
6.5 Courts
The role of the courts in a dialogue model
primarily consists of an interpretive and
enforcement role. In the UK, courts are
considered to be public authorities in their own
right, and are therefore required to themselves
comply with the Human Rights Act including
when making judgments. This has allowed
the UK Human Rights Act to have ‘horizontal
application’53 as the courts may apply human
rights principles to cases that involve private
parties, in the fulfilment of their own duty to
consider human rights when making decisions.54
The Commission has heard mixed views on
whether this approach would be acceptable
in Australia. Some consultees indicated that
it may be problematic at the federal level,
because of Chapter III of the Constitution
which prescribes a strong separation of powers
between judicial and parliamentary bodies, and
therefore limits the extent to which Parliament
can control a court’s judicial functions. In light
of this, the Commission does not recommend
the UK approach of including courts as public
authorities in the same manner as executive
bodies.
The Victorian Charter Review recommended
that the Victorian Government more actively use
its existing regulation-making power to clarify
whether entities are or are not public authorities,
including relevant bodies under national
schemes.51 It was noted that this could
FREE AND EQUAL A Human Rights Act for Australia 2022
151
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات