The Residential Tenancies Act establishes an
independent complaints mechanism in the form of
Tenancy Services and the Tenancy Tribunal.
Alongside the Act, Healthy Homes Standards
establish minimum standards for heating,
insulation, ventilation, moisture, and draught
stopping. These standards are intended to ensure
the quality of rental properties and keep them
warm and dry.
The Residential Tenancies Act exempts transient
and short-term housing, i.e., accommodation
provided for less than 28 and 90 days respectively.
When emergency and transitional housing
initiatives were originally developed, the intention
was that both forms of accommodation would
be provided for periods shorter than these
timeframes:
At the time that the Government’s current
transitional housing and emergency housing
programmes were introduced, it was not
envisaged that clients would remain in the
services for extended periods of time.61
52
Human Rights Commission
However, legal advice was provided to Cabinet in
2020 that the increasing average length of stay
in emergency accommodation and transitional
housing meant this accommodation was now likely
to be subject to the Act. Following that advice,
Cabinet made the decision to exempt emergency
housing system accommodation (both emergency
accommodation and transitional housing) entirely
from the Act, rather than amend the legislation to
create new provisions specifically for these types
of accommodation.
Since that legislative change in 2020, residents
living in the emergency housing system are not
entitled to the protection contained in the Act,
including access to Tenancy Services and the
independent Tenancy Tribunal. While transitional
housing providers have their own internal dispute
resolution procedures that residents can follow,
these are not independent, there are no review
or appeal processes, and disputes cannot be
escalated to independent bodies such as Tenancy
Services and the Tenancy Tribunal.