E
Tuberculosis (TB) and
other Respiratory illnesses
1993-2018
,u ,p vkj lh % iPphl o’kZ&vla[; vk’kk,a
Nhrc : Twenty Five Years-billion Hopes
33. What are the directions of NHRC regarding periodic medical
examination of the prisoners?
All the prison inmates should have periodic medical check-up
particularly for their susceptibilities to infectious diseases and the irst
step in that direction would necessarily be the initial medical
examination of all the prison inmates either by the prison and
Government doctors and in the case of paucity or inadequacy of such
services, by enlisting the services of voluntary organizations and
professional guilds such as the Indian Medical Association. Whatever
be the sources from which such medical help is drawn, it is imperative
that the State Governments and the authorities in-charge of prison
administration in the States should immediately take-up and ensure
the medical examination of all the prison inmates; and where health
problems are detected to afford timely and effective medical treatment.
34. What symptoms necessitate investigation for tuberculosis?
Early suspicion of disease like tuberculosis which is very common in
India especially when the patient presenting with un-resolving fever
and respiratory symptoms. In such cases chest X-ray should be used as
a screening tool and a sputum test for con irmatory microbiological
diagnosis of TB. Enhanced case inding should be undertaken in certain
“high risk” populations such as prisoners.
It has been commonly observed during medical investigation at NHRC,
the prescription of prisoners generally lack proper history taking
about the duration of cough and examination indings. But
simultaneously the antibiotics (suggestive of respiratory infection)
were being prescribed on multiple occasions. This practice creates
doubt in the mind of investigators about non initiation of timely
screening for TB.
It is suggested that in prison, history taking and examination indings
should be done as well as properly recorded. In cases of unreliable
history (which may often be a case at prison), multiple episodes of
respiratory infections over a short duration of 1-2 months or nonresolving respiratory symptoms/infection (cough>2 weeks) should
also be taken as indication for TB screening. History of contact with
prisoner having tuberculosis should also be investigated for TB.
FORENSIC INVESTIGATION | 39