the Labour Inspectorate has no authority to investigate work practices that involve
exploitative under-payment of child workers.
44.
Furthermore, New Zealand’s current regulations that govern health and safety
standards in the workplace are not CRC compliant and only provide more rigorous
workplace safety standards for children aged under 15.23
Article 37(c) – age mixing in prison/places of detention
45.
There has been some substantive progress made over time to enable this reservation to
be lifted. The Department of Corrections has in place a “test of best interests”
operational policy, the purpose of which is to assess whether an 18 or 19-year old
prisoner deemed vulnerable may be held in a youth wing.24
46.
Furthermore, as referred to the background information above, the Ministry of Health
has developed detailed guidelines to assist District Health Boards comply with the
requirements of Article 37(c). The guidelines establish a robust set of criteria that
must be met before a child or young person may be detained in an adult mental health
ward. External monitoring and oversight is provided by District Inspectors.
47.
However, despite these policies, there have been no formal steps made by the
Government towards lifting this reservation.
Recommendations
48.
The Committee may wish to consider including the following questions in its List
of Issues for the New Zealand Government:
Given the substantive progress made towards lifting its general
reservation and its reservation under Article 37(c), when does the
Government intend to initiate the formal withdrawal of each reservation?
If the Government does not intend to initiate the withdrawal of its general
reservation and its reservation under Article 37(c), what are its reasons
and, more specifically, what legal or policy barriers to withdrawal exist?
Given the Government’s reservation under Article 32.2 concerning a
minimum age of entry to employment, what steps is it taking to ensure
that all statutory minimum employment standards and workplace safety
laws are otherwise compliant with the CRC?
Tokelau
23
Health and Safety in Employment Regulations 1995, part 5
http://www.corrections.govt.nz/resources/Prison-Operations-Manual/Movement/M.03-Specified-gender-andage-movements/M.03.html
24
11