Part III The practice: What NHRIs can do to contribute to the process of change
Section I Getting ready to engage
9.4. KEY CONSIDERATIONS WHEN PLANNING TO INVOLVE
PERSONS WITH DISABILITIES
The deep level of engagement that article 33(3) envisages requires forethought on the part of NHRIs. The
following are some of the factors that NHRIs might need to consider when planning their engagement
with civil society.
Balancing involvement with maintaining independence: Some NHRIs have expressed concern
about the impact of involving persons with disabilities on their ‘de facto’ independence, as required
by the Paris Principles. However, others suggest that such involvement helps NHRIs to maintain
their independence, in particular from government. Perceptions of a lack of independence, or more
accurately, a surrender of independence because of the presence of civil society might, in the eyes of
some, taint any recommendations for change that emerge from the partnership. There is no inherent
necessity why this should be so.
Setting out clear terms of reference in advance in relation to any mode of involvement will help NHRIs
manage the expectations of persons with disabilities and their representative organisations, as well as
allow NHRIs to demonstrate to others that such involvement is not compromising their independence.
Preferring organisations ‘of’ persons with disabilities as against organisations ‘for’ persons
with disabilities: In many countries, persons with disabilities have historically been the object of
charitable organisations and NGOs ‘for’ persons with disabilities. These groups have frequently spoken
on behalf of persons with disabilities without their consent. Many such organisations have sought to
reform their own approaches, increasing the degree to which persons with disabilities are involved in
their governance and the delivery of their services. NHRIs will likely find themselves engaging with these
organisations. Nevertheless, NHRIs should always prioritise engagement with organisations ‘of’ persons
with disabilities; that is, organisations led and run by persons with disabilities.
Reaching out to hidden voices: As noted in Part I of this Manual, the term ‘persons with disabilities’
encompasses a large and highly diverse section of the population, both in terms of the nature of
people’s impairments and health conditions, their age, gender, ethnicity, socioeconomic status and
other characteristics, and the particular circumstances, barriers and human rights risks they face.
NHRIs should strive to reach out to the widest possible community of persons with disabilities, both
directly and through their representative organisations, if they exist. There are many ‘hidden voices’ in
the broad disability community. Strenuous efforts should be made by NHRIs to reach out and include
these voices. These include persons with psychosocial or intellectual disabilities confined to institutions,
disabled prisoners, people who are ‘non-verbal,’ people who are ‘hidden’ within their communities,
children with disabilities, those living in rural communities, women and girls with disabilities, persons with
disabilities in minority ethnic and indigenous communities and those with diverse sexual orientations,
gender identities and sex characteristics. NHRIs should take concrete steps to ensure that the voices of
this broad range of persons with disabilities are heard. This may require the NHRI to commission expert
support, including from organisations of persons with disabilities.
Maintaining ‘open channels’ to the broader community: The modes of involvement developed
by the NHRI must be accessible to all persons with disabilities. For example, information should be
available in alternative formats; presentations should be delivered in an accessible way, mindful both
of people with sight impairments and intellectual disabilities; provision should be made for people who
use hearing aids or sign language; and meetings should be held in accessible venues with accessible
transport links.
If technology is available and reliable, web-conferencing and web-casting can be powerful ways
to involve persons with disabilities who might otherwise be unable to travel to meetings. It is also a
particularly useful way to reach people in isolated areas. NHRIs should consider how to offer ‘open
channels’ of communication for persons with disabilities who may live in situations of vulnerability, such
Chapter 9: Working in partnership with civil society: ‘Nothing about us without us’ | 111
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات