The petitionee argued that hallyangchum of this region is a male dance and a female initiate
may damage or transform its standard form and thereby erode its cultural value.
Based on our investigation, the Act on the Safeguarding and Promotion of Intangible Cultural
Heritage specifies the basic principle of the preservation and promotion of intangible cultural
properties as keeping the archetype intact, which is a set of intrinsic values, while recognizing
collateral changes and succession-induced variability, and we concluded that the petitionee's
argument runs counter to this principle and lacks reasonable grounds. We also concluded that
it cannot be deemed reasonable to exclude women from the selection of scholarship students
solely based on gender without even consulting relevant experts about whether it can affect the
preservation and succession of the archetype.
B. Discrimination Based on Appearance and Physical Condition
Restricting Those with Color Vision Deficiencies (except for Mild Forms) from the
Police Official Recruitment Examination
We recommended on April 13 that the Commissioner General of the Korean National Police
Agency improve the provisions that uniformly restrict those with color vision deficiencies
of certain degrees regardless of task type from applying for the police official recruitment
examination in the Enforcement Rules of the Decree on the Appointment of Police Officials.
The physical examination qualifications for the current police official recruitment examination
exclude those with all forms of color vision deficiencies except for mild forms. The Korean
National Police Agency argued that the ability to differentiate between colors is crucial for the
use of a firearm when arresting criminals and that police officials cannot be selectively appointed
to tasks other than those that involve arresting criminals.
We confirmed that even those diagnosed to have color vision deficiencies of moderate or more
severe forms on the clinical test executed and produced as evidence by the petitionee manifest
symptoms varying by case, not uniform symptoms, and that some even demonstrated results
identical to those without color vision deficiencies. We had already concluded in our previous
decision that it is discriminatory to uniformly restrict those with color vision deficiencies from
applying for the police official recruitment examination regardless of task type and viewed that
this case has no grounds or evidence to be decided otherwise.
108
Commission's Major Activities
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات