NATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION
returning on a truck after a visit to Baba Sher Shah Wali shrine for prayers. Few of the passengers
sat on the tool box. When truck driver was reversing the truck, one of the villagers Shinda
Singh, who stood on the tool box, suddenly came in contact with electric wires overhead. All
the persons sitting on the tool box were affected by the electrical current. Shinda Singh, Roshan
Singh, Harpal Singh and Nishan Singh died in the government hospital and six persons received
burn injuries.
4.78 The Deputy Commissioner, Tarantaran, in his report, submitted that four persons had died
on the spot and six others were injured in the accident. To compensate all the affected persons,
Hon’ble Chief Minister of Punjab has sanctioned ` 5,50,000/-, i.e., ` 1,00,000/- each has been paid
to the next-of-kin of the deceased persons and ` 25,000/- each has been given to the six injured
persons. According to another report from O/o Chief Electrical Inspector to the Government of
Punjab who got an inquiry conducted into the incident, the vertical clearance of the line was not
as specified under the Rules, the sag of the line was loose and no guarding was provided under
this 11 KV line. It was also stated that loose sag of 11 KV line was the cause of this accident. It
was concluded that this accident could have been avoided, had the supplier erected and maintained
the installation in a proper and safe way. By not doing so, the provisions of Regulation 58 and 70
of Central Electricity Authority Regulations, 2010, were violated by the supplier.
4.79 Upon consideration of the above reports, the Commission took the view that a clear
case of violation of human rights of the deceased persons and injured persons was made out.
As reported ` 1,00,000/- each has been paid to the next-of-kin of the deceased persons and
` 25,000/- each has been paid to the six injured. In the opinion of the Commission, the amount
paid to the next-of-kin of the deceased is not adequate. A notice u/s 18(a)(i) of the PHRA,
1993, was issued to the Chief Secretary, Government of Punjab to show cause as to why the
Commission should not recommend additional compensation to the next-of-kin of the deceased
persons, who lost their lives due to negligence of the Electricity Department.
4.80 Since no reply was submitted by the State Government. The Commission on 23.01.2017
recommended to the Government of Punjab, through its Chief Secretary, to pay additional
compensation of ` 1,00,000/- (Rupees One Lakh only) each to the next-of-kin of the deceased.
Proof of payment in this case is awaited.
g)
Pollution and Environment Cases
14. Alleged Pollution Caused by Karoli Plastic Bottles Manufacturing Industry, which is
established in Residential Area Inhabited by People Belonging to Scheduled Caste, in
Village Abhineniguntapalem, Guntur, Andhra Pradesh
(Case No.1046/1/6/2016)
ANNUAL REPORT 2016-2017
57