HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION OF SRI LANKA, Annual Report 2020
The need for strict action as required by the law against hate
speech
While acknowledging and thanking the Sri Lanka Police for its tireless
service to curb the COVID-19 pandemic, the Commission urged the acting
IGP to take strict action against incidents of hate speech during the COVID19 pandemic. HRCSL in its correspondence noted that it has received a
number of complaints of hate speech directed against the Muslim
community in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. The Commission
requested the IGP to take stern legal action against the perpetrators of such
acts regardless of their status, in terms of Section 3 of the ICCPR Act No. 56
of 2007, as it is imperative to prevent any unrest that can result from such
hate speech. It also drew attention to the guidelines on the application of the
hate speech law issued by the Commission in the previous reporting year.
Limiting Freedom of Expression in a Democracy: The Need
to Strike a Lawful Balance
By letter dated 25 April 2020 the Commission stated that it observes a spate
of arrests by the police on the basis of statements made over social media,
especially in the context of the spread of COVID-19 virus in the country and
pointed out to the acting IGP that any action taken to limit freedom of
expression and other such rights in a democracy, even during a period of
emergency, must be within the framework of the law, namely, the
Constitution and Sri Lanka’s international human rights obligations. It
further stated that those laws require that limitations on rights should
comply with the tests of legality, proportionality, and non-discrimination
and guidance in this regard could be sought from the rich body of
authoritative jurisprudence developed by the Supreme Court of Sri Lanka. It
further emphasized that both the Constitution and our international human
rights obligations permit adoption of extraordinary measures during
emergencies without compromising human rights protection or the Rule of
Law. As such, HRCSL recognized the need to lawfully curb misinformation
that can cause panic and pose a serious threat to public order and public
health when the entire country is facing an unprecedented public health
crisis. However, the Commission underscored that such arrests must be
legally valid, must not be arbitrary and disproportionate, and must not be
28